[ Rules ] [ ot / g / m ] [ pt / snow / w ] [ meta ] [ Server Status ]

/ot/ - off-topic

Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File(20 MB max)
Video
Password (For post deletion)

Read the rules and usage info before posting.

The VPN ban is now in effect on /ot/, see this update post for more information

File: 1751244388747.png (354.25 KB, 517x570, elsiefujo.png)

No. 2584462

As always, report and ignore bait.

ITT: Discuss the controversies and disagreements between fujoshi, yumejoshi, and himejoshi. Note: yumes and self-shipping aren't necessarily the same thing. Slashers and fujos also aren't exactly the same, though they heavily overlap.

Topics include:
>Whether there is a causal relationship between consumption of yaoi/slash and trooning out
>Voyeurism vs. self-insertion
>Yaoi men vs. bara men vs. 3DPD gay moids
>Does the fiction a person consumes need to comport with their real-life ideology and politics
>Female creators' portrayal of male-male sex/romance vs. male creators' portrayal of female/female sex/romance
>Do women read yaoi or slash as an "escape" from misogyny IRL
>Can women be "porn addicts" and/or why are women held to higher standards of moral purity than men
>Whether (or why) lesbians can/cannot be fujoshi
>No True Fujoshi (i.e., does enjoying "straight-with-extra-steps" shit like A/B/O, Mpreg, cuntboy, etc. make someone "less" of a fujoshi)
>General moralfaggotry

Previous: >>2523554

No. 2584465

The threadpic is a work of beauty

No. 2584498

I hope this thread discusses more yaoi and the like and not irl 3DPD bullshit haha.. ha..
>>2584462
You did good OP. You did real good.

No. 2584522

>>2582978
>>2582843
even though western artists have bad art and book cover trends I feel like their writers and writing itself are not that different than asian ones. For novels it’s best to look for recs on places like the m/m romance goodreads group and m/m romance books reddit where there are mostly adult women. it’s easy enough to avoid things you don’t like because goodreads users love to tag everything. authors I hear about the most are KJ Charles and Cat Sebastian (I have not read any of their works yet so idk) And I’ve been meaning to read Alice Winn’s In Memoriam sometime too.

No. 2584750

Do fujofags ITT prefer original works or fanfiction?
I can digest either honestly. I usually prefer content for my ships but some people have such appaulijg tastes that i'd be better off reading a non-consequential oneshot doujin

No. 2584753

>>2584750
i prefer a mixture of both especially if said original work is featured in the fanfic like on ao3

No. 2584772

>>2584750
Reminds me of harada. One shots are better

No. 2585443

File: 1751322335490.jpg (162.89 KB, 665x416, tumblr_mrccbumKv11serp85o1_128…)

>>2584750
When it comes to Japanese stuff, I prefer original manga to djs. But as far as Western m/m goes, I prefer fanfic, because as you can see from what >>2583370 posted, Westerners have shockingly shit taste when it comes to art styles, because they prioritize being ~yooneek~ over being aesthetically pleasing. Thankfully, if it's a fic, you don't have to see a shitty art style. That said, there are exceptions: I'm surprised no one brought up Teahouse yet. Into the Smoke has a decent art style, too. Check Please has a somewhat ugly art style, but the good writing makes up for it. Starfighter is hot if you can put up with the lore making no sense kek. Ride or Die has an art style that reminds me a little bit of Motorcity. But yeah the pickings are pretty slim when it comes to Western comics, almost everything is either badly drawn or full of gender nonsense. Or it's capeshit: if you're alright with cape slop, Midnighter and Apollo is good because it can be read stand-alone, as opposed to anything with Wiccan and Hulking which requires a bunch of background reading to understand what the hell is going on.

No. 2585445

>>2584772
Harada is the best, and I will take no arguments.

No. 2585454

>>2584750
Both. Who am i to turn down good yaoi based on where it comes from?

No. 2585461

>>2585454
The problem (for me) is finding good yaoi. Not shitty gendie mlm garbage or weird bara scat porn.

No. 2585503

>>2584750
I like original works more, but in general I've never been much for fanfic.

No. 2585519

>>2584750
Reading wise (like with words only) I prefer fanfic because I'm reading about something I'm familiar with so it's easier to get immersed in it and it won't bore me to death hopefully. But manga and anime wise I do prefer original stuff because it feels like starting a new thing from scratch and it's exciting to get to know the franchise, story and characters. Doujins aren't bad but they're usually a bit too short for my liking and leave a lot to desire or too OOC and I just skip the dialog and look at the smut since they rush the way they get there anyways. I want a DJ that's like a fanfiction in story telling but with art that resembles the original franchise and is like multiple chapters but that's probably hard to make. So I just look at fan art instead lol. I'll say I get more invested in non-canon ships from things I watch because of the story being complex and long and them having great dynamics, so seeing fan work with them as a ship is pretty exciting. While original yaoi is the same boring settings and dynamics over and over again it's hard to get into it anymore. It's always
>school setting
>band setting
>office setting
>CEO and some poorfag setting
>bully and victim setting
And so on. Banana Fish and Yuri on Ice had the right idea with an actual story happening around the ship and pushing them together, but the former chickened out on showing it and the latter wasn't as passionate as I'd like. I'm lame and I want a shounen slop tier yaoi story. That story about some kid who died in summer that was trending a while ago had potential but also chickened out. Tokyo Ghoul was rumored to originally be a yaoi but the writer chickened out and I can totally see it, it would've been better as a yaoi. No. 6 was cool but they separated at the end unfortunately. Zanyou no Terror had yaoi bait in it and it could've worked tbh but again they chickened out. Hell even Jojo chickens out on that and all the gay couples are side characters who die and we don't get enough of them to invest in them. I need my sense of grandeur in my ships PLEASE.

No. 2585523

>>2584750
Both. It's easier for me to get invested in works that don't revolve around romance and have a greater plot. So fanfiction is great, but I also want to get spoiled with explicit pandering sometimes. I like VNs and one-shots and BL manga that revolve around a plot. It's like reading fluff after angst or enjoying something sweet after eating something savory, it's best to rotate between original works and fanfiction.

No. 2585525

>>2584750
You gotta use the original works in order to make the yaoi more believable. I want my 2D moids fucking while in character, you feel me?

No. 2585565

Yaoi is not representative of actual gay men, and this is a good thing.

No. 2585574

I grew out of yaoi but I'm not sure why. I read so much of it as a teen and in my early twenties. I try to chase that same yaoi dopamine high but I find myself annoyed by all the porn and just swiping through sex scenes to skip them, which just makes it boring in turn. So I dont even try to read yaoi anymore. I wish I could go back to pure yaoi brainrot tbh. Fujoshis have it good.

No. 2585634

>>2585574
I think because when we were younger the novelty and taboo of it being porny was exciting, now we're older and know better and want actual stories and writing before the sex but nope, they sex from the first page. Vidrel.

No. 2585639

>>2585634
Discovering explicit yaoi as a teenager legitimately changed my brain chemistry.

No. 2585650

>>2585565
Exactly.
>You're sexualising MLM!1!1!
I would rather eat my eat through a bag of rocks than watch 3d moids going at it, it's like watching wild animals on the discovedy channel, I can't will myself to look.

No. 2585692

>>2585639
Same tbh. It made me into being "sexually dominant" if that makes sense and kinda shaped my taste in men in a way.



Delete Post [ ]
[Return] [Catalog]
[ Rules ] [ ot / g / m ] [ pt / snow / w ] [ meta ] [ Server Status ]