>>490345I agree with the lightning in a bottle part but I don't think it was only the pandemic, even though the pandemic is why it became a lot of people's first gateway gacha. But I think it also maintained it's popularity, and that no other gacha will ever reach the same heights, for two factors. Look at the fanbase and you can see two groups.
1. People who played gacha before and who went into Genshin because it had a much nicer budget and better gameplay than what they were used to. Before Genshin on twitter the gachas I'd see dominating would be rhythm games like the idol stuff, or games like Granblue Fantasy or FGO, which is also a pretty moid dominated franchise. None of these games innovate their gameplay and their pity system can be even worse than Genshin's. So by gacha standards Genshin was already an elevated experience. It felt like a regular game.So by gacha standards it was already good. There was fanservice for the female characters but it didn't look as bad as other games so it got a lot of women interested, and cool male characters were also some of the first promoted so it got that audience too, where at first they would think they'd be treated equally unlike other games.
2. The jrpg anime fantasy audience. I think this point is more relevant to Genshin's current staying power. Genshin got the type of normie crowd who loved jrpgs. A lot of those mid budget jrpgs you used to see on handheld consoles are basically obsolete now. But a lot of women like them and that audience is still there. Genshin managed to get that audience that Square Enix tossed aside when they were too busy trying to make the new Final Fantasy more like a manly action game. So you have the Final Fantasy crowd with nothing to really play in between games. The Fire Emblem people too in between the long wait between games. And series like the Tales games which are basically kill now thanks to management. Genshin just had what it took to attract this bigger crowd that gave it success. If Genshin only attracted the waifufags or only teenagers whose only contributions to fandoms are just kinning and discourse, it wouldn't have the big fanbase of artists and writers that it does. Most good fic writers after all are grown women with jobs, not annoying teenagers or moids who only care about building harems. That's why Genshin got so huge, it has the same elements that those type of female fans like in games. Being a live service game doesn't hurt the popularity either. FOMO is huge now with how fast moving social media is, one and done canons don't build the same longevity in fandoms anymore but people love to be into the big popular thing.
All this to say this is why no gacha game can ever really be the Genshin killer. New waifu games will take incels, some husbandofags will go to otome but not all husbandofags are yumes, or just want to play a dating sim. no matter how polished it is. None of these new waifu games or new Hoyo games will ever reach the heights Genshin had because it's not just because of the pandemic, its because of the other qualities Genshin had. Dawei is too prideful and stupid to see it because he wish it was it was Honkai instead. He doesn't want to bring back the old designers or writers. He wants it to be Honkai. Making all these spinoffs and side games, trying to turn Honkai into the next MCU, none of that is going to work. The "roots" he should be going back to aren't waifus, it should be simple anime fantasy. But I bet he resents that something that isn't his baby got so popular. He doesn't care if he tanks Genshin's reputation, he's already filthy rich. He really is such a loathsome CEO. If another gacha wants to kill Genshin , they'd have to do what Genshin did but better and reach the normie audience, but it seems they all want to chase the waifu audience instead, with diminishing returns each time. Someone should make a youtube video on Genshin's downfall. I have a feeling the ending is going to be a trainwreck that ruins most people's associations with the canon just like Jujustsu Kaisen and Tokyo Revengers ending did for those series. It would be nice to finally stop seeing people praise this waifuslop incel pandering game as deep and meaningful storytelling.