File: 1642960622915.jpg (54.52 KB, 500x532, Tumblr_l_42527481055129.jpg)
No. 4098
Gender critical and radical feminism define gender as sociological (feminine/masculine) and sex as biological (female/male). Woman is defined as an adult human female. Radical feminists seek to abolish gender as it is used by patriarchy to oppress women socially, reproductively, and financially. They strive to preserve women's spaces (such as restrooms, locker rooms, and health care providers) and areas of artistic and intellectual expression separate from men.
Trans ideology posits that one's gender is self-determined based on one's feelings and defines woman as the characteristics and behaviors traditionally ascribed to females by society. Increasingly, transactivists are conflating gender and sex and asserting that a person can self-identify both gender and sex.
Gender critical feminists strive to maintain the distinction between gender and sex. The conflation of gender and sex erases the biological reality of women, eliminates women-only spaces, and disestablishes women as a protected class. Existing laws and legislation currently being passed around the world allowing for self-identification on legal documents do not differentiate between gender and sex.
The acronym
TERF (Trans-Exclusionary Radical Feminism) is used primarily by transactivists and their allies to denigrate radical feminists and other women who express gender critical ideas. Transactivists portray TERFs as violent oppressors by virtue of their ideas alone.
Posts of related news and web articles are welcome. Posts of photos, videos, and blogs of transactivists for the purposes of discussion and critique are welcome. Please refrain from derailing, infighting, and ad hominem attacks. This thread is not intended for the general discussion of feminism, sexuality, misogyny, or misandry.
Previous threads
>>>/ot/221232 01
>>>/ot/231926 02
>>>/ot/248302 03
>>>/ot/267773 04
>>>/ot/281458 05
>>>/ot/296475 06
>>>/ot/312419 07
>>>/ot/320422 08
>>>/ot/331248 09
>>>/ot/341517 10
>>>/ot/351615 11
>>>/ot/360163 12
>>>/ot/377370 13
>>>/ot/387259 14
>>>/ot/396926 15
>>>/ot/408612 16
>>>/ot/418616 17
>>>/ot/429238 18
>>>/ot/441471 19
>>>/ot/448777 20
>>>/ot/454392 21
>>>/2X/5 22
No. 4104
File: 1643128687422.jpg (265.75 KB, 1080x1080, 271544493_113465747873515_6502…)
No. 4105
File: 1643128717017.jpg (37.1 KB, 882x875, 269444075_136340885439644_3101…)
No. 4106
File: 1643128776516.jpg (32.87 KB, 500x518, 1631945150182.jpg)
No. 4107
File: 1643128799588.jpg (527.97 KB, 3432x1929, E-cWTOsWQAQ3VGy.jpg)
No. 4108
File: 1643128915909.png (165.08 KB, 584x550, 215588221_597955544925328_5862…)
No. 4109
File: 1643128956682.jpg (125.12 KB, 1162x1785, 211330341_10159461035734828_14…)
No. 4110
File: 1643128989846.jpeg (61.54 KB, 736x487, 1622137214171.jpeg)
No. 4111
File: 1643129057549.png (500.97 KB, 865x1806, 1624235619856.png)
No. 4112
File: 1643129255139.jpg (75.64 KB, 750x750, 9skz765w6s371.jpg)
No. 4113
File: 1643129316029.jpg (109.16 KB, 1057x771, tumblr_49e518de12a175429dda6fb…)
No. 4114
File: 1643129533332.jpg (52.41 KB, 500x455, 1621414558402.jpg)
No. 4115
File: 1643129667474.jpg (70.54 KB, 672x840, 182498996_10225348884970818_90…)
No. 4116
File: 1643129737402.jpg (98.06 KB, 634x960, 83641179_10158121673310979_273…)
No. 4117
File: 1643129789401.jpg (128.5 KB, 521x677, 156946483_125452916173419_8751…)
No. 4118
File: 1643129884271.jpg (37.25 KB, 558x960, 153563944_469829914049248_5250…)
No. 4120
>>4099>a lesbian that doesn't want to date a MTF or a gay that doesn't want to date a FTM, are "genital obsessed" and transphobicbut
>TRAs want to implement terms such as "uterus-havers", defining people by their genitals
>TRAs and trannies are proud of being trans whenever it is convenient, for example calling others transphobic, begging for representation, or acting like a disadvantaged minority.but
>TRAs and trannies do not want to be seen as "transgender" or different at all, and insist that they are biological women or men. Do not want to be separated into trans-specific sports or bathrooms, want to invade women's spaces instead No. 4141
>>4099>Nonbinary people don't owe you androgynybut
>Androgynous people owe you nonbinary(By which I refer to GNC men and women constantly being asked if they're nonbinary/trans or being pressured to identify as such)
No. 4143
File: 1644168670557.jpeg (128.49 KB, 542x415, FF4D32CD-69AA-4AC0-A489-AADB57…)
Parents File Lawsuit After 12-Year-Old Girl Attempts Suicide Twice at School After Secret Meetings
https://www.theepochtimes.com/parents-file-lawsuit-after-12-year-old-girl-attempts-suicide-twice-at-school-after-secret-meetings_4247010.htmlAfter a 12-year-old girl attempted suicide on school property twice after months of secret meetings with a school counselor, her parents have filed a lawsuit.
On Jan. 5, Wendel and Maria Perez received a call from Destiny Washington, who identified herself as a school counselor at Paterson Elementary School (PES) in Fleming Island, Florida, part of Clay County District Schools. Washington told Mr. and Mrs. Perez they needed to come to the school immediately. Washington said it was about their daughter, a sixth-grader, but would not reveal any further information.
When the Perezes arrived at the school they waited in the lobby for 20 minutes before someone came to escort them to a room where Washington, PES Principal John O’Brian, Vice Principal Courtney Schumacher, and a Clay County Schools Police officer were waiting. Mr. and Mrs. Perez were instructed to sit down. According to the federal lawsuit obtained by The Epoch Times—filed Jan. 24 by Child and Parental Rights Campaign, Inc. on behalf of Mr. and Mrs. Perez—Washington told the Perezes the reason they were called to the school was because their daughter “had tried to commit suicide by hanging herself in the school restroom.”
Washington then informed the parents the reason why their daughter tried to kill herself was “because of her gender identity issue” and the fact they would “would not be in agreement with these changes” because of “their Christian Catholic religious beliefs.” As the Perezes sat reeling, Washington stunned them again. The Jan. 5 suicide attempt was the second effort. Their daughter had also tried to hang herself the day before. Without explaining how the child survived the first attempt, Washington insisted school staff was not aware of the first attempt prior to the second.
According to the complaint, the daughter sought guidance from the counselor because she was being bullied. She liked video games, which is something her peers say boys do. A friend “confided she thought she was transgender,” and the girl thought she could be transgender as well because “she wanted to be strong and free ‘like a boy.'” When the child went to speak to Washington, she saw “a lot of posters, literature, and other promotional materials related to LGBTQ ‘pride’ in Washinton’s office.” The girl “thought those materials were ‘cool’ and asked Washington if she supported transgender people.” Washington said she did, at which point the child told Washington, “In that case call me ‘M’ and ‘he.’”
Through weekly private meetings over the next few months, the complaint alleges Washington endorsed the belief that the child “could be a boy” and called her by the male name and pronouns. Washinton promised she would not tell the girl’s parents. However, the promise of confidentiality did not extend to the child’s peers. Washington began addressing the child by the male name in front of her friends without the girl’s permission. The child was humiliated. The bullying, for which she sought help from Washington, escalated. As the child became more confused and depressed, Washington told the girl she would get all of the teachers to start calling her by the male name.
After being told their daughter had tried twice to hang herself on school property because their Christian Catholic beliefs conflicted with her new identity and being told they had been kept in the dark about the months of private meetings because of “confidentiality issues,” the Clay County Schools Police officer then informed Mr. and Mrs. Perez that their daughter had already been placed in the back of a police car and was going to be transported to a mental health facility under the Baker Act, regardless of whether or not they approved.
According to the complaint, Mr. and Mrs. Perez “were not given the option of transporting their traumatized daughter to the facility or even traveling with her to provide comfort. Instead, their suicidal 12-year-old daughter was taken in a police vehicle to an emergency room, where she stayed until 4 a.m. when she was transferred alone, without the comfort and/or support of her parents, to another emergency room and then admitted to the behavioral health unit at Wolfson Children’s Hospital.”
Named in the lawsuit are David Broskie (individually, and in his official capacity as Superintendent of Clay County District Schools), John O’Brian (individually, and in his official capacity as Principal of Paterson Elementary School), Courtney Schumacher (individually, and in her official capacity as Assistant Principal of Paterson Elementary School), and Destiny Washington (individually, and in her official capacity as counselor at Paterson Elementary School). Twelve causes are outlined. A jury trial is demanded.
The Father’s Story
“This counselor said we were there because our daughter tried to commit suicide,” Wendel Perez recalled of that day to The Epoch Times. “The counselor alleged that it was because of her gender identity issue, and they knew we would not be in agreement because of our religious beliefs. We’re Catholic Christians. When I asked why they didn’t notify us about these surreptitious meetings with the school counselor, we were told by an administrator that confidentiality issue prevented them from telling us about them.”
“Confidentiality” was the same reason given to January Littlejohn after she discovered school officials in Leon County, Florida, held a private meeting with her daughter. As reported by The Epoch Times on Aug. 23, several school officials met with her daughter in secret to draft a “transgender gender nonconforming student support plan,” which was used to record her child’s new non-binary status, “preferred name,” and “preferred pronouns.” The 13-year-old child was even allowed to determine she would “be comfortable rooming w/either sex” on overnight school tips without the knowledge or consent of the parents. Staff also decided the parents would not be informed of anything involved in “implementing this plan,” and staff were instructed not to “include gender-specific pronouns when speaking w/parents.”
Perez said when he and his wife arrived at the hospital, they were under the impression their daughter was going to be with someone. But they discovered their daughter had been by herself the whole time. More disturbing was when she was moved into the behavioral health unit, where one of the staff members called their daughter by the boy’s name used by Washington. Perez said his daughter immediately corrected the staff member, saying that was not her name and she told him her real name. What Perez wants to know is how the hospital staff member knew to address his daughter by the fictitious name in the first place. “Who was in charge? Perez asked rhetorically. “We weren’t allowed to go with her. The school was in charge. The school provided all of the information to the hospital. The school coordinated with the hospital.”
She was away from us for a week, with limited access to family,” Perez said. “Then she was released to us on January 12, and she’s been with us since then.”
Asked how his daughter was doing now, Perez said “she’s doing great. She’s a happy girl like she was before. She is relieved she isn’t at the school anymore and she does not want to go back. She is getting her schoolwork from her teachers and doing her work from home.”
No. 4160
File: 1644841270939.png (80.96 KB, 345x474, 1641806125234.png)
I wish I had friends in my country who do not worship the feet under troons. I lost my previous friend group of almost 10 years at least partly because I could not keep my fucking mouth shut about my radfem views. It started with me being naive and thinking saying "hormones should not be given to kids" is a normal view to have - that triggered my friends nonbinary girlfriend to have a panic attack and crying. Other friends best friend is a FtM Aiden who brags about all the dick they are sucking and what kind of pocket pussies they have bough (for what purpose??). Well, it's been a couple of years now, it doesn't matter any more.
I don't know if I would fit into any legitimate feminist groups either, since my humor has been tainted my years and years of image board browsing, and I tend to laugh at some non-PC jokes occasionally.
It's just frustrating. I wish I knew this before accidentally stumbling upon gc thoughts. I would have closed my eyes, kept my mouth shut and kept repeating TWAW in my head
No. 4162
File: 1644843942715.jpg (25.57 KB, 321x377, tumblr_8e088a90110289715c26b49…)
>>4161Oh god, my condolences anon. Must be fun trying to be a little handmaiden for his delusions and smile along (that sounded derogatory, I was not meaning that sorry lol).
Funny that you mention therapy - from observing one of my only remaining friend's journey through psychology university degree, therapists are "brainwashed" into the gender speak already in school. It is very much libfem central over there, even though the people that get into the school are very intelligent, as they only take in like 1% of applicants.
I recently started a genetics course in my university, I almost burst out laughing at the professor talking about intersex mutations. He just described them as flat out abnormalities and how some, like XYY, are more prominent in prison population since it causes aggressiveness etc. It was such a different approach to what I am used to in social media. (I'm all for intersex rights and shit and I don't think they are freak or anything it was just so shocking)
No. 4164
File: 1644848563830.jpg (120.48 KB, 828x827, tumblr_29be8dde81759f80eb29234…)
>>4163I don't blame the therapists, I believe some want to seem woke just out of fear. I has (or is proposed to become?) actually illegal to become anything but affirming, since it is "conversion therapy". They could lose their job they have spent years and god knows how much money getting. I've seen some reddit screenshots of people complaining they were not cleared for HRT, and wonder if they should report the doctor / therapist for mistreatment…
Lol the bra thing makes me think of a twitter post I saw recently, something about women deserving comfortable bras or go braless. OF COURSE some fucking brave and stunning fat scrote was in the replies telling how putting his moobs in bras make HIM feel so euphoric and feminine uwu :3c At least some women told him to fuck off. I have seen some rise in pushback towards these fuckers, I hope more people come to their senses.
No. 4169
>>4168What's with the other boards?
I've been trying to vent in ot but it just won't let me but glad this fits here too. I had to tell a bra size calculator if I was afab or amab and it felt like a slap in the face.
No. 4179
File: 1645146009851.jpeg (598.53 KB, 1170x1555, 58F944CC-62E5-4C6A-801D-9337F1…)
You will only lose… your blind faith in trans ideology!
No. 4232
>>4200Bleak but, I used to be a pickme mra antifeminist retard before the trans thing blew up. It finally opened my eyes to the reality that males really do hate all women and that I wasn't special or different, just a useful idiot. I told myself I was nlog to protect my ego from the crushing reality that we actually do live in a fucking patriarchy and that feminists were right all along. I'm not sure that would have happened if I didn't see everyone bending over backwards to protect obviously mentally ill degenerate coomer scrotes. It was in looking for a different take on the trans issue that I started reading things written from a woman's perspective. I had been subconsciously avoiding anything created by women because I had been so conditioned to think "they" (we) were inferior idiots, and that only by reading and watching men could I become better. I was actually shocked by how articulate and reasonable women are. The lies of the mra movement became so embarrassingly obvious I couldn't believe I ever entertained them. In a fucked up way I have to thank the trans movement for waking me up from that nightmare, and I feel like I'm not the only one. This may be overly optimistic, but I feel like the women's rights movement will only get stronger. The sexism inherent to trans ideology is so blatant that it works as a litmus test to see who actually has compassion for women and who is just pretending for social cred. It forces you to confront the most comical, overly exaggerated textbook form of sexism, and watching people fumble with this concept is the blackest pill. I will never be able to go back. I will never unsee the truth. And I don't think I'm alone. I sense a rage bubbling beneath the surface, a class consciousness beginning to form. I see it in comment sections, in tiktoks, in passing remarks. I have hope for the future, the more oppressive trans ideology gets, the more undeniable feminism becomes. We may be too scared to speak publically at the moment, but that only stokes the fire in our hearts. From each and every injustice those small fires will quietly but steadily grow until someday becoming an inferno; and when that day comes, I don't think men will be ready.
Sorry for the blog and fanfiction.
No. 4279
File: 1646067123542.jpg (384.1 KB, 1080x2096, Screenshot_20220228_084732.jpg)
I feel a little better seeing that the news in my country don't pander to degenerate troons.
There was this news article about a TIM who abused a minor, and the article always refers to the abuser as male, only using his "female name" in quotation marks.
In the past year there's been a chunk of the teenage population that's been pushing for all this gender special bullshit but I'm glad to see it's not catching up where it actually matters.
No. 4300
File: 1646473619802.png (23.64 KB, 613x204, a.png)
On the one hand I appreciate he came out and said him turning transgender and then non-binary was all stuff of his fucked up psyche, but on the other hand, how could he be stopped when the only person who did refuse to his delusions was fired and then "cancelled" by him? Most of the people on his way were afraid of that but he also accuses them of not doing anything. It's a weird situation which played a huge part in the non-binary shit we have today.
Despite "accusing" people for not stopping him in the whole article, at least he doesn't victimize himself in the last sentences.
https://www.dailysignal.com/2019/03/10/i-was-americas-first-non-binary-person-it-was-all-a-sham/ No. 4306
>>4302Most moids literally cannot grasp the concept that gender roles are not the same as biological sex. They think women not wanting to be domestic sex slave barbies is the same as denying the existence of x any y chromosomes.
We are being "punished" for rebuking our contrived, subservient role because that's all the see women as.
No. 4317
File: 1646696021521.jpg (292.86 KB, 1042x1899, Tumblr_l_100034498090408.jpg)
More proof its all misogyny
No. 4321
File: 1646762615989.png (414.09 KB, 871x707, garbagio.PNG)
Hey gc anons, I am coming from the regular vent thread in /ot/ because I think my vent was so heavily gc related that it probably fits better here. So my longtime friend who I have known literally since we were both babies shared this tweet and said it was a "good point" and it made me so upset I almost went off at her in dms, even though we never fight and she is generally a very sweet person. I was so furious that someone could see surgeries women are often pressured into by men's expectations like BA and cosmetic labial surgery as "gender affirming" as though looking like a porn star caricature somehow makes you look "like a woman." It's only "gender affirming" in the sense that it does work to legitimize and affirm the bullshit concept of gender identity, but of course that is not what the poster or she meant in spreading this idea. I am also deeply disgusted that such a line of logic could be used to justify stunting a young girl's growth and giving her a life threatening mastectomy to remove healthy tissue, as though the only options for a young girl to see in her future are being a bimbo or a surgical imitation of a man. It's just so wrong and I am incredibly disappointed, I don't know how an otherwise intelligent and caring person like my friend came to believe something like this. I'm glad in the end I decided not to confront her because she would probably just hate me forever for being a terf, but either way I feel like we can't be as close anymore. We already grew apart a bit because we live in different cities now, but after this I just need to distance myself from her overall. It sucks.
No. 4428
>>4425I love your idea! It would be nice to make radfem theory more accessible, especially since a lot of the books are out of print and mostly found online as pdfs, and it feels like a lot of people just don't know it's out there. I love SCUM too, although I'm not sure I would use it to introduce people. A QR code sticker sounds like a good bet though, if you can get some printed. I used to have a link to a collection of PDFs of Dworkin's work too, I could try and dig it out of my bookmarks if you're looking for any.
It's honestly a shame how repressed their writing is, because I feel like Solanas and Dworkin and so many other feminist authors had such a viscerally beautiful way with words.
If you're looking for a slightly less anonymous community to discuss this stuff, I really suggest making a Tumblr and connecting with radfems on there. We have a pretty big community, used to have some issues with drama but I don't think it's nearly as much of a problem anymore. No. 4430
>>4428Drop some usernames to follow,
nonny, I haven't been on Tumblr for years but would join for sisterhood
No. 4439
>>4369>How did the trans community evolve from mostly self-hating homosexuals to mostly narcissistic heterosexuals?Honestly, handmadens giving AGPs a platform and trying to snuff out HSTS
The more that happened, the more AGPs joined in and now there's fuck all HSTS in comparison
It's really a shame because I'd be okay with the existance of HSTS (maybe not even sharing spaces with them. okay trama-nonies?) but AGPs should be having every move they make monitored, not being emboldened
No. 4467
>>4442Oh gosh, I meant to check the board to see if anyone wanted links but I forgot, thank you for your service! I think that's where I got my pdfs too.
>>4431For an intro, I really love Cordelia Fine's Delusions of Gender. I feel like she's a little more low-key, and while it was published in 2010 and the "woke" language has changed quite a bit since, it's not the kind of stuff that would immediately turn off a casual normie TRA type. It breaks down the myth of brain sex and goes into how socialization affects men and women, but particularly women. It even discusses a study on how it can impact (passing, old school HSTS mostly) trans women, and it's a pretty good deflection against
TERF accusations without pretending they're actually women. It's been a little while since I read it, but I also remember it being pretty funny and easy to get through. I don't think it really hits you over the head with the radfem theory, but I do think it would be hard to read and understand it without coming to those conclusions yourself. I think I got my pdf from the same blog the other anon linked, but if it isn't there I could try to figure out a way to post it.
>>4430Other anon's recommendations are great, I'll add a few of my own. Some are strictly political but a few are just funny gals or also talk about their cool hobbies, it's nice to have a mix so radblr doesn't feel like doomscrolling.
antiplondon
opabiniawillreturn
kronkk
magnetictapedatastorage
d3nt4l-d4m4g3
queen-mayhem
long-leggged-socialist
meangirlpolitics
balkanradfem
No. 4484
>>4483Yes, I also love how she compares the gender cult to a religion. It totally is. They literally believe in a gender soul that can only be 'freed' once they mutilate their bodies, and shun the non-believers like heretics. Luckily I'm on
TERF island but if I ever get some genderfag coming up to me asking me about my pronouns or whatever, I will say "Oh, I'm not religious".
I'm pissed she got yeeted from Youtube though. I worry the likes of Posie Parker and Karen Davis will be next. I know Posie isn't necessarily radfem but she is still based nonetheless, and I see her getting more radicalised as time goes on. I also fear Magdalen Burns will have her treasured channel removed one day too. Even beyond the grave, she continues to peak people daily.
No. 4494
>>4493I'm so sorry for you and your daughter.
Your boss is right, though. She will get pressure to trans, and it probably be from her peers and teachers. You need to get ahead of it and talk to her about this. I mean, not now. But like once she starts elementary school, especially if your school public school system is in thrall to gender identity. Read Irreversible Damage and books like that so you can be aware of the arguments that will be used to try to convince her to transition. Also, make sure she doesn't spend a ton of time online. That's a huge gateway for this.
I'm so sorry you have to go through all this just because your daughter is tomboy. The world is so fucked up.
No. 4575
>>4562Generally I'm just very open about feminism and if they're TRAs, they'll whine and derail with moid gender shit. If they don't do that, you'll eventually end up at the truth that misogyny oppresses female people for being female, and then you've basically got your answer.
They could also be conservative but tbh even conservative women hate men half the time. They'll cushion everything with "I'm not a feminist, but-" and "Of course not all men, but-" but half the time all they need is another woman who's safe to share their real thoughts with.
No. 4709
File: 1649668715469.jpg (106.36 KB, 1804x899, trans identification by birth …)
I'm planning on doing some amateur data analysis using data from some surveys the U.S. government has been doing to assess how the public is faring during Covid. In it, they ask for age, birth sex, identified sex, and myriad other things. I intend to use data they collected between July 2021 and March 2022 (over 675,000 responses) to try to calculate trans identification across different demographics.
Unfortunately, there's not data for minor sexual/gender identification, only for adults.
Source for my data:
https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/household-pulse-survey/datasets.html#phase3.4Note: One interesting thing about this data is that you can choose either "male" or "female" as your birth sex, but for your identified sex, you can choose one of four options regardless of your birth sex:
1. Male
2. Female
3. Transgender
4. None of these
This means that males who say they identify as female are recorded separately from males who say they identify as transgender.
On the graph, the top line includes people that identify as neither "male," "female," or "transgender." However, I wasn't comfortable assuming that all these people actually are trans, since I'm sure some GC types would tick that box angrily. The bottom line represents people who explicitly said they identify as the opposite sex or as trans. The actual % of trans identification likely falls somewhere in-between.
No. 4710
File: 1649669551568.png (82.67 KB, 1326x1235, hsts vs trans vs nonbinary.png)
>>4709A funny artifact of separating out people identifying as the opposite sex vs identifying with the label "transgender" is that you can see a strong divide in their sexual orientations.
There's an official Tableau visualization of LGBT data for the overall adult population here:
https://www.census.gov/library/stories/2021/11/census-bureau-survey-explores-sexual-orientation-and-gender-identity.htmlThe former group is very straight relative to the latter, which is overwhelmingly "lesbian" and bisexual.
No. 4711
>>4696Same, but as someone who grew up without any religion but could see others partake in it I already knew how easily people blindly believe made up shit for no reason. I didn't think people would fall for new lies so quickly though, it's scary.
There is literally no way to look at the current gender movement as anything but a religion. It's a blind belief that goes against reality and science that can't be questioned or you're an evil
terf "sinner". Just like buddhism you don't need a god to worship and instead strive to be the "true version" of what your "soul" tells you to be.
No. 4712
>>4710Final samefag for now.
There's some issues with this dataset. People born in 1933 and earlier are all grouped together under that birth year, and there's bizarrely high reported rates of being "transgender/non-binary." I don't have the number right now, but if I remember correctly, it was around 20%, so I'm chalking that up to an artifact of bad data collection or management or something.
There's also a serious lack of young adults answering the survey. There were 4-5x as many answers per birth year for people born in the 40's-80's than there were per birth year for people born in the late 90's. Out of the entire pool of respondents, about 1.0% were binary trans (see official government infographic), but this calculation was made without controlling for the fact that there were disproportionately few young respondents, who are disproportionately likely to be trans.
No. 4826
File: 1650228816878.jpeg (767.23 KB, 1242x1826, DA979DF6-19DF-4CC2-B15A-F285F4…)
Idk if right thread but
I know picrel is wrong but I’ve always had trouble putting a coherent argument together because that’s just not my strong suit. I get too flustered and annoyed and I feel it on the tip of my tongue but it’s like I have brain fog. Anons, how do I argue against this shit. I need a cheat sheet.
No. 4910
File: 1650812306662.jpeg (246.91 KB, 1920x1920, D7D7B6FE-AC4B-467B-BF92-5E275C…)
They are a special kind of evil. If every other letter in the alphabet people is uncomfortable but you, maybe it’s you that is the problem.
No. 4933
>>4826First, don't argue with troons because they fetishize any female attention. They'll say you're jealous or something. Second, they think any woman above 5'3 who doesn't have D cup breasts, huge eyes, tiny nose, and other very stereotypical characteristics are men. Although they also argue you can't tell if a woman is trans even though they already have listed a huge list on tips to help them do just that.
So they're both saying trans women are no different than real women while also saying there are "women who could be trans" as in, they do realize that even if those women have masculine characteristics, they definitely aren't trans. Also most people don't stare at women and them trying to figure out if someone is trans would be considered transphobic, even.
No. 4934
File: 1651068416963.png (191.64 KB, 552x520, janeclarejones.png)
No. 4939
File: 1651081379526.jpg (570.34 KB, 1080x1080, 20220427_193945.jpg)
I just saw this today and found it hilarious.
So without the T the lgbt would be cohesive, inviting and more serious but with the T it' an absolute clusterfuck
No. 4998
File: 1651405554564.png (86.69 KB, 1178x372, downtown.png)
Statistics Canada released the results for the 2021 census recently. There's some interesting (and predictable) stuff in there, like that people who identify as non-binary are more likely to live downtown in highly-populated cities, skew younger, and suffer from mental illness.
On their website it says, quote:
"Generation Z was born in the Internet age, and millennials came of age during a time when the Internet was changing the way we gather and process information. The Internet, along with social media and web-connected personal devices, may have contributed to the increasing awareness of gender diversity—especially among younger generations—by providing transgender and non-binary individuals with virtual support communities."
What a gentle way of talking about it…
No. 5022
File: 1651527915442.png (85.78 KB, 887x382, BC.png)
>>5019The previous pic is just the top cities for the amount of nbs living downtown. The census also says that a higher than average amount of trans and nonbinary people live in british columbia.
No. 5023
File: 1651528305727.png (73.17 KB, 1177x611, numbers.png)
>>5022>>5019That said, Nova Scotia had the highest.
I'm intrigued by Nunavut having the lowest amount while the Yukon has one of the highest. Seems random.
No. 5031
File: 1651592282110.png (43.41 KB, 641x721, Capture1.PNG)
https://www.smh.com.au/national/inclusive-language-risks-dehumanising-women-top-researchers-argue-20220126-p59red.html>Breastfeeding community educator Jacquie Ducat said she did not take issue with such language changing as she realises desexed terminology still includes her.Well, yeah, of course "non-men" includes us, but that's not the point. (Correct me if wrong.) I know I menstruate, have a uterus, could give birth, am not a man, etc. I don't feel excluded by that language.
I feel dehumanized by that language. That language rejects my very personhood. I don't get to be a "mother" anymore, I'm a "breastfeeder" or "birth-giver." You know, like a fucking dairy cow.
This kind of shit is what they're calling us in the scientific and medical literature. There's no way this won't have an impact on the treatment we get from the medical professionals who are being trained currently. They'll see us as talking versions of the corpses they practiced procedures on.
No. 5044
File: 1651630840484.png (75.63 KB, 895x217, nb.png)
No. 5053
File: 1651665739053.png (123.15 KB, 1200x527, biological essentialism.png)
No. 5068
>>4934Nonnas, tinfoil time but I can't shake the theory: all the troon encouragement is some kind of psyop that started after the Women's March. There were pornsick AGPs before that, but it's exploded since then, pushed on easily infiltrated online spaces like 4chan and reddit. Somebody saw Women uniting as a political class for the first time in ages and decided to break it apart by introducing dissidents by manipulating men.
Since then enough of them have trooned out it's become self sustaining and is working better than they could have hoped.
Like I said, it's tinfoil, but the same thing happened with Occupy and idpol groups "showing up" to derail it.
No. 5102
File: 1652065029923.jpeg (649.65 KB, 1170x1713, 32D75EDA-D240-45FD-945D-F9CB7E…)
Idk where this goes, but I loved it so much, I needed to share.
No. 5238
>>4998>1.5%The absolute state, that's surprisingly a lot
>>5018You want them to go with the MacKay or MacDonald?
No. 5256
Just watched this video by a Chinese YouTuber who mostly talks about tech. There are a lot of parallels to how TiMs describe gender dysphoria in her experience. The tl;dw is that she was raised and treated as a boy because of China's one child policy, but she was never tomboyish and it didn't feel right (she doesn't blame her parents for it, and doesn't want them to be bashed). She's also a lesbian. She always admired hyperfeminine women, and as she grew older, she leaned heavily into looking/feeling as feminine as possible. She feels very out of place and depressed in conservative clothing, and has a harshly negative reaction to being seen as "boyish" in appearance. She doesn't even go by her birthname or show childhood photos because she doesn't see that person as her anymore. She maintains that she and other high femmes don't present the way they do for male attention or for sexual gratification, but others have a hard time understanding it, so explaining is hard. Her breast implants are actually prosthetics, which she describes as "gender-affirming top surgery", and she states that many lesbians in Asia get top surgery to remove their breasts for the same reasons, hers is just the other way around. She describes her way of dressing as a "10 year old's idea of a sexy lady" (hence the cutesy touches to her outfits), and though it can give a bad first impression, she's not hurting anyone, despite having "some glitches" in her gender expression
What do you guys think? My first thought was "Lying troon" when she brought in the dead name aspect and admitted she didn't even have breasts before going in for prosthetics (she claims many Chinese women don't) but she doesn't read as male to me, and she has a very butch Uyghur girlfriend, so I don't know. She said she supports anyone who's "trying to be their real self" (aka trans people) and that many people must have had it "much harder than her", but I can't help but feel that she might be heavily projecting her own experience onto TiMs. Like, in theory, it's similar, but what's the relation between a traumatized girl who was raised as a boy growing up leaning into all the things she was denied as an adult (whether it might be over the top or not), and a western boy who's (at most) a little wimpier than the other boys, then grows up, fries his brain on porn and tries to live out a literal porno fantasy of what he thinks a woman is? It's annoying to think of AGP transbians who are also into tech/programming being like "Omg she is literally me". It's sad to me that there might be a significant amount of actual women with this very particular, hyper-specific experience of being forced to live as male, but it's still white men with fetishes who get heralded as "the face" of it
No. 5260
File: 1652273289630.webm (776.07 KB, 576x1024, Cigarettes out the Window by T…)
These people are so annoying. My god. She's 20 too.
No. 5269
>>5256>though it can give a bad first impression, she's not hurting anyoneExcept she is. I'd in fact argue she's hurting herself the most because as you say she's
>a traumatized girl who was raised as a boy growing up leaning into all the things she was denied as an adultI don't see her coping with this by having surgery to physically turn herself into a living sex doll as healthy. If she wanted to heavily lean into stereotypical feminine expressions like dresses, makeup and painted nails, that would be one thing, but why is her concept of femininity so sexualized? Why can't she have just accepted her natural body and dressed girly but not pornographically? There is clearly more going on here than only being treated as a boy when she was little. I don't think she should be diminished for how she dresses, but obviously she knew the sort of objectification and male attention she would garner by presenting herself this way. She seems like she's in denial about her real reasons to me.
No. 5276
File: 1652363574275.png (226.61 KB, 598x733, Joe_1.png)
>>5275reminds me of what happened to Joe Hawley, this incident happened over a year ago but its still perfect example of why you can't ever win with TRAs, Joe Hawley the former frontman of the 2000's Indie pop rock band Tally Hall(the one's that made the Ruler of Everything song) got DM'd by an underaged nb Ayden who asked him if he could put his pronouns in his bio, he politely refused and got into argument regarding non-binaryism and pronouns and in this conversation his "
problematic" views were revealed
see like most normie libs he thinks trans people are "
valid" and believes Transphobia is real, but he doesn't buy into that Idea that anyone can be non-binary, he also believes that children don't have the mental capacity to know if their trans or not and shouldn't allowed on hormones and referred to some "trans affirming" surgeries as multination(which they are) and that got him cancelled, like the whole of woke twitter fucking hates his guts now for views that aren't even remotely offensive and likely what the average normie lib believes in
No. 5277
File: 1652428451924.gif (2.43 MB, 498x266, 1649421652453.gif)
I was wondering if someone could explain to me in detail why exactly MtFs are so attracted to lesbian. Is it really a porn induced fixation? or is it also that they dont want a typical dominant male position in the relationship because they are too weak to be someones rock to rely on.
just confuses me becausse lesbian relationships do have butch/femme dynamics but thats not always the case. ive known butches to date and marry and femmes to date and marry.
i just dont understand why exactly it is lesbianism that they are drawn to. holy grail of "nobody stuck her dick in her" kinda possessive fixation? is it truly the most unattainable thing for a guy and their drive to deserve and aquire everything driving them to do so? i am just so desperate to understand nonnies
No. 5280
File: 1652447132541.jpg (120.82 KB, 720x592, Screenshot_20220513-065704_Chr…)
My autism can't tell if this is a humble brag or a joke after the "totally cool Stacy" part. Anyone else find ovarit difficult to enjoy because it's filled with grifters and 40yo pickmes?
No. 5288
>>5277It’s a few things off the top of my head, but I can deep dive if you want.
To start men fetish lesbians because they view them as unattainable and untarnished women. They’ve in their heads never been with or belonged to another man so they can get their virgin fetish and weird power leveling from that. Because sex between two women could never “be real sex.”
Porn pushes lesbians like crazy so they typically end up developing a full on fetish manipulating their sexuality into more severe obsessions. Porn addicts also lower their own sensitivity, sperm counts and give themselves Eds and require more stimulation seeking out more severe forms of their fetishes like men raping lesbians and conversion porn. Or tranny and lesbian porn etc.
It’s also a validation thing like they’ve tricked the truest of terfs and women and it makes them better than the other trannies. Etc.
No. 5320
File: 1652814174660.png (465.31 KB, 1080x1401, Screenshot_20220517-115923.png)
Apparently requiring women on corporate boards is "unconstitutional"
No. 5328
File: 1652881381649.png (28.83 KB, 1140x257, 456789.png)
This is from _rational_ wikipedia. Idk how rational it is to just say something is false without telling the reader what is correct then. Funnily enough the rational wiki seems to think otherkin is bullshit but trannies and sex changing over the course of a human's life is totally possible and real.
No. 5406
File: 1653229409625.png (643.56 KB, 895x741, 77.png)
>Retired doctor wrongly prescribed sex-change treatments to patients as young as nine, tribunal hearshttps://www.yahoo.com/news/retired-doctor-wrongly-prescribed-sex-194128007.htmlI have no words. This is just disgusting.
No. 5438
File: 1653338562071.jpg (112.48 KB, 720x670, Screenshot_20220523-224126_Tum…)
Some people are so close to getting the point yet still so far away
No. 5499
File: 1653739093929.png (43.07 KB, 1141x517, manipulation.png)
I have just made a post about the wikipedia Dianic Wicca article and decided to compare some past versions of it. Is anyone else not only extremely tired but also worried about twannies editing wikipedia articles pandering their bullshit.
No. 5694
File: 1654296462001.jpg (96.57 KB, 821x1382, Tumblr_l_23694758711052.jpg)
No. 5708
File: 1654373105442.jpg (405.52 KB, 1079x1467, Screenshot_20220604_220308.jpg)
Kekkk, had a breakdown on main. Might've cried a little there but fucking hell.
No. 5716
>>5708>trans friends, family and partner is nbThis isn't surprising. Some people aren't just blind because they don't know any better, they make the choice to remain blind out of misguided love. They don't ask questions because their personal community follows a very specific mindset, and going against it has been framed as "literally killing" people. Even if all the things you said rang true to them (and they probably did), you're asking them to shoulder the pain of knowing their friends and family are making a terrible mistake, and they can't say or do much about it. It's the sort of knowledge you just can't go back from, and if you're liberal or left-leaning surrounded by similar people, the stakes are so much higher. Most people aren't brave or brutally honest enough for that. There's also a more twisted aspect of feeling like you're a "good ally" for discarding people for wrongthink. It's a messed up psychological punishment/reward system that preys on people's guilt and empathy
I'm sorry this shit happened, I've also had friendships end because I didn't want to swallow the BS. Now I keep most people at a safe, polite distance if they seem too "woke", and I can tell it kind of bothers them, but I know once you get too close, it's either you live the lie with them, or what you posted ends up happening. Unless they're literally in love with you, like ready to risk it all, the best you can do is drop a few peaking questions or statements and just let them think it over themselves. I know this post is 6 hours old, so I hope you're feeling better, nona. One person isn't the end of the world, you can and will make better friends who don't have those sorts of attachments (or at least won't place them above their bond with you) ♥
No. 5728
>>5716I can't thank you enough for your thoughtful message, it really helped. It is simple in the end.. They can't force me to accept swapped genders, I can't force them to understand why. I just deleted him. We've been friends for ten years.. It is devestating. I should've kept my damn mouth shut, but by now I also don't want to..
It was about another friend of mine calling me a nazi. I'm from Austria. Our nazis are a whole lot different. So I had a full break down on my main Snapchat about that. That I simply believe that people can't change their sex, and that made me a nazi in someone else's view. Which is truly hard, seeing where I come from. Our nazis will break your fucking arm or leg for fun. In some states we have brotherhood watches made up of nazis because they believe the police aren't doing enough against rape and thievery.
That's where I come from. So yes, I wrote a very thoughtful piece about people calling me that, what I truly believe in.. As in.. Respect for every single person, health care, psych care, etc..
It fucked me up being called a nazi. It truly did. My countries nazis aren't that nice or commendable. They're not based. They're truly, truly awful and violent.
Thank you though. It truly helped me understand and also be okay with it. It simply is. Friendships pass and there is no failure in it. Thank you.
No. 5734
>>5733Burgerland and
terf island are also both having HRT shortages for women with actual medical needs while trannies are getting theirs.
No. 5794
File: 1654700979121.jpeg (274.76 KB, 1563x1992, 82AFDBAE-6A56-4C02-86C0-B7B328…)
No. 5797
File: 1654701104749.jpeg (105 KB, 634x611, 3ED88717-E748-4EB2-AAAE-9D6691…)
>>5796It’s just fucking sad
No. 5799
File: 1654718488149.jpeg (464.07 KB, 1080x3699, DFF6D256-A796-4F6E-AE47-F1B564…)
Nothing like threatening violence am I right? Ffs
No. 5848
File: 1654932514123.jpg (127.16 KB, 1080x866, Tumblr_l_252917194223482.jpg)
No. 5858
File: 1654971239733.jpeg (135.72 KB, 1900x1425, fa266137-8c88-4d8d-a94f-cec53f…)
I'm from Norway and people know I'm a terf and they'll tell me "but this girl completely passes its impossible to tell". It literally looks like what it is, a little boy in makeup?? Like I don't get why he is hailed here as the perfect passing tranny, I see boys looking like him all day every day sans makeup
No. 5925
>>5864Oh yeah with the smell I was talking about my public hair.
I feel like armpit smell is the most random thing. Sometimes I don't shower for days and there's nothing, sometimes I smell 5 minutes after leaving the shower. I shave them because I hate the feeling of having hair there and the hair keeping them moist. I generally have sensory issues with things on my skin though.
No. 6019
File: 1655930406155.jpeg (356.74 KB, 828x1057, 13209F97-C412-40D6-9B84-8BF910…)
>>6012Trying to find some for you. This one talks about one of the theories why but disagrees with it.
https://curejoy.com/content/masturbation-cause-hair-loss/ No. 6020
File: 1655930619030.jpeg (191.41 KB, 828x624, D43D198B-C985-4FD8-9DAA-4202E7…)
>>6019https://mrmindblowing.com/nofap-hairs/There’s a lot of nofap men that talk about it.
No. 6023
File: 1656007094593.jpg (140.33 KB, 1134x266, artfight.jpg)
>>6017Surprisingly, it was trans people that made me really appreciate being a woman.
Unrelated, I was looking up this thing among artists called Art Fight that starts next month. Lo and behold, the very first rule mentions transphobia. Not homophobia, not racism. Nice to know where the priorities are. Noped out of there real fast.
No. 6025
>>6012wrong thread
>>6017why "in an alternate dimension I'd be trans" and not just "in an alternate dimension I'd be a man"
No. 6046
File: 1656228299693.jpeg (94.9 KB, 827x845, 3A04FAA8-31D0-4FC4-AA41-177E18…)
found this in the comments of a youtube video for a womens only capsule hotel in japan
there were a ton more gc/terfy comments too, it gives me hope
No. 6419
File: 1660844948611.webm (3.11 MB, 540x960, ftm butcher.webm)
saw this video on tumblr and i found it suspicious and of this dude has a track record of medical malpractice. Tifs found this tiktok hilarious while the evil Terfs found it concerning and they were right as there were links about his malpractice and people who sued him. but despite that, there were still supportive comments
https://www.reddit.com/r/ftm/comments/eciytk/dr_crane_malpractice_lawsuits/https://4thwavenow.com/2018/03/26/update-san-francisco-phalloplasty-surgeon-now-with-8-malpractice-suits/https://thepostmillennial.com/gender-dysphoric-patients-suffer-at-the-hands-of-unethical-doctors No. 6504
File: 1662707582417.jpg (100.11 KB, 1080x577, Tumblr_l_52586285326348.jpg)
"female brain"
No. 6513
File: 1662708560296.jpg (236.39 KB, 422x2048, Tumblr_l_52606170658449.jpg)
>>6512everytime i think ive climbed to the top there is another higher peak
No. 6535
>>6524I wish I knew,
nonny. I’m in the same boat as you. One of my best friends is a he/they woman who I’ve known for years and I love her to bits but I’m constantly worried that one of these days I’ll out myself as an evil
terf and she’ll drop me. I think I’m the only gnc person I know who doesn’t identify as trans/non-binary. It’s so stifling. I wish we could all meet in real life somewhere.
No. 6568
>>6545What sucks is that most of these older normies are anti-troon because they're socially conservative or religious. Finding another young, progressive woman who is a legitimate
TERF seems impossible. (I live in NYC.)
No. 6605
>>6525i just feel so tired of this city sometimes. the homeless situation is depressing. i get harassed by homeless men while i wait for the bus. they scare me. i carry pepper spray with me whenever i go home after class.
>>6535my friends are well meaning. i think theyre not that involved with politics beyond what they see in major news events. Or their trans friends appear mostly relatively normal and aren't the most degenerate kind walking outside with cat ears. I wonder if we had someone like the boob teacher in canada it would peak people here…
>>6545Yeah. We both dislike it, but they mostly dislike it because they think women should act a different way and we dislike it because we dont believe in any of this gender personality shit. I dont really want to hang out with them either. I honestly wish I could find other women who agree with me at my college but we would probably get harassed out of school.
No. 6627
File: 1664807835876.jpeg (Spoiler Image,6.58 KB, 203x249, 9876543456.jpeg)
Everything feels so bleak right now. Is there a way out of genderism that preserves women's rights? Or are our options going to be Misogynistic Mormons VS Misogynistic Troons? It feels like over the past year people using the GC and radfem label have veered sharply to the right. I'm predicting that the right is about to appropriate the language and theory of feminism to push their own agenda, just like how TRAs appropriated feminism to push their agenda. I think it's going to follow the exact same pattern. Any true feminist organization will be infested and overwhelmed by trad misogynists who will use feminist aesthetics and terminology to pursue anti-feminist goals.
No. 6716
>>6504so let me get this straight, satoryuga - a korean woman who is not even a confirmed radfem - blocked a troon male or a few troon males who were sexually harassing her, then the trannies doxxed her and got her assaulted/beaten irl by korean moids while also writing out graphic detailed racist rape and killing fantasies about her all because she blocked/didn't want to be sexually harassed by troon mra incels
what the actual fuck? how can anyone want to associate with an ideology that is supportive of this disgusting behavior?
No. 6827
>>6826nevermind, she's braindead. And so am I for prematurely linking this. At the very least I got to see where the
terf = nazi argument came from.
No. 6903
File: 1670102914105.jpg (1.09 MB, 1440x1440, gncwomen.jpg)
Sorry for blogposting about the obvious but I guess something just hit me today. I was trying to find a list of gnc woman to share with a friend who is questioning if she is an enby. I have tried subtly peaking her and she “sees my point” on a lot of stuff but is still quite far into the gender ideology and thinks it’s a positive thing.
Today I find out that, according to google, “gender non conforming” has now been completely replaced with non-binary, as a term. And all gnc people throughout history are now described as enbies, such as Grace Jones and David Bowie. I always thought those two concepts remained at least somewhat separate so am quite upset to see that’s not the case. How can you be gender non-conforming when you either don’t have a gender or change your gender to accommodate the stereotypes you conform to? How can you, as a woman, think so little of women as a whole that you identify out of womanhood (your material reality) because you didn’t want to conform to made-up stereotypes? How is that a cool or alternative thing to do?
When lesbians and feminists have historically been gnc - rejecting mainstream female beauty standards and stereotypes, these same women-centered women are now not women at all! I'm so sad about what this means for the future of women.
No. 7009
Just thinking about the fact that I need a long list of short concise texts debunking the most common trans arguments. They have to be simple enough that people understand it easily and factual enough to be credible at the same time.
It all just gets so muddy when all their arguments contradict each other and you try to walk on egg shells to not offend them too much so you have to pick and choose which of their lies you believe in at the given time so they'll even listen to you for 5 seconds.
One example I've run into is their attempt to still their cognitive dissonance by redefining sex and going from saying
>You can't change your sex, but gender is separate and different
to instead saying
>Actually sex is a group of things like phenotypes, chromosomes, social roles, and you CAN change those so that means your sex has changed
And it's so easy to fall into the trap and try to refute them point by point, when at the bottom there is no reason to accept that that IS the definition of sex, or that it "should be". Changing your sexual "phenotypes" basically just means appearance, like "I chopped my boobs off so my chest is flat, which is phenotypically male = therefore my phenotypical sex is male".
Adult human female. It truly is the ONLY acceptable definition.
Adult = the fully grown form of a living being
Human = our species
Female = the sex that is developed around producing the large gametes aka eggs (whether or not this production is functioning or not doesn't ever matter - if you unplug your TV, it's still a TV. If your TV came in broken, it was still made to be a TV. A female child or a post menopausal woman are still both female and at no point in history has that ever been questioned.)
No. 7020
>>7016Because women have different medical needs. Because our sec decides those needs. Because male doctors operating on female patients have a 15% increased risk of death. Because biology itself is a
terf. Gender is bullshit. Sex is real and impacts our physical needs of care and there’s nothing wrong with that. We deserve cars that are built to our skeletal frames so we don’t have a 26% increased risk of dying in car accidents or serious injury.
No. 7024
>>7016>answer that isn't terfywhy do you need an answer that isn't "terfy"? are you lost?
Sex is innate and immutable and not only makes a huge difference in our physical bodies, but changes how we experience the world. On average, women are smaller and not as physically strong as men, 95% of rapes are towards women and 1 in 3 women experience sexual assault in their lives, we have the ability to get pregnant which not only puts us at risk but prevents opportunities and freedoms afforded to men, we bleed every month which can result in pain, health problems and stigma. Note: not all women have ovaries and wombs but 100% of those that do are women. Women are more likely to experience poverty and we own only 2% of the world's land. In some countries we have no freedoms based on the fact we are women. Some women are denied education, forced into sex slavery, FGM and other kinds of abuse. These things don't happen because they wear dresses and like lipstick. It's because they are women. From the moment we are born, we learn to fear rape and male violence. We also learn to protect and care for men above our own needs.
SOME women will experience very little or perhaps next to none of these problems. These will mostly likely be rich or knowledge-class women who are well protected, educated, healthy and comfortable. They don't have to experience much of "the real world" as it were. Most of us don't have this luxury. It will always be the women at the bottom who will pay the highest price.
Gender is a bullshit made up social construct that equates womanhood with femininity (eg, dresses, make up, being polite and agreeable) and men with masculinity (being strong, confident, aggressive). The
reality of being a woman has fuck all to do with femininity. Believing any different is incredibly sexist and regressive.
Don't you ever wonder why we have single sex spaces in the first place? don't you wonder why girls and boys have separate physical education/sports?
>Free to be whoever we wantThis is the lie being sold. Don't equate female empowerment to "Women are like men". We are not like men. We have our own power. We have different needs and desires. What is good for men, isn't necessarily what is good for women (and
very often is the opposite).
However, we can be what kind of women we want. We can be strong, we can be tough, we can be smart etc. but we are not men. To pretend we have the same opportunities or lived experiences is not only delusional and doing us a massive disservice but is actively destroying our hard-won rights.
No. 7026
>>7025it makes me laugh seeing the TIFs discuss TIM's behaviour in a way that is almost indistinguishable from women talking about their male oppressors but they're literally just swapped the names around.
Also how transwomen are suddenly dominating sports now they can play with women, and transmen don't even want to compete in male categories because they know they wouldn't stand a chance. strange, huh.
No. 7269
File: 1672575886066.jpg (69.72 KB, 540x571, 62af1e3cda6c77ad52f8893104615e…)
No. 7275
>>7269kek hilarious
But i hate this "what about transwymyn?!?" dumbass argument so much.
>TIMs are welcome in every single fucking other shelter except one that JK madenothing is stopping them using any of the others that pander to them, at the expense of women in need
>Even if there weren't any other shelters, why don't any of these huge million-pound funded trans orgs or TRA celebs make one?why don't they take a leaf out of jk's book and actually support their community as they claim such support is so desperately needed. no one is preventing any of them from creating trans shelters.
No. 7472
>>7419I think they do really believe it because TRA rhetoric parrots other legitimate liberation movements. Like SRS, the original ideas are butchered into a crude imitation and upon inspection you can easily see that but the social pressure is so greatly against really interrogating those ideas. So they follow along assuming that second guessing it would be like second guessing if homophobia or racism is wrong. The whole game has been a fantastic bit of jiu jitsu, using people's goodwilled desire to live and let live against themselves until they're cornered into going along with preposterous and regressive ideas.
If you dare to try to wake them up, it helps to point out the double standards that still privilege males, like TIMs being the social media reps for tampon companies instead of TIFs, or headlines erasing the word "woman" but using the word "man", or how male transphobes are pursued less aggressively than so-called TERFs when the latter is far less dangerous to trans people than the former. Or you can play dumb and ask questions to try to understand the ideology until they inevitably end up in knots.
No. 9249
>>7534>the real problem is more likely that they're simply ignorant about the issue. Most of them write off demented AGPs as not True Trans and their conception of a trans person is the meek HSTS minding his own business or the chill FTM from their friend groupThis is why when you want to peak a TRA/handmaiden friend you have to start lightly by showing them those AGP troons under the guise that it's the "bad" ones who ruin it for other (real) trans people. They will only listen if they think it helps the poor innocent (real) trans people, so you have to cherry pick some (plenty to choose from) diaper fetish AGPs and act like they're disgusting for trying to turn being trans into a fetish, just like those bigoted right wing conservatives are saying they are!!!
Then you move onto the sexist and fetish ones "a REAL trans woman wouldn't be so sexist to (cis) women", "a real woman wouldn't send cis women rape threats" etc. Gotta lightly guide them to peak without telling them directly what to think.
No. 9372
>>9368This is agenda of modern media.
Appear to support feminism, but in reality make it work against women. Make it look like feminism focuses on unimportant issues, make it sound illogical with bad arguments and most importantly, make it include and be dictated by men (trans). Meanwhile try to portray actual feminism as hate and extremism.
On the other hand, appear not to anti-feminism, right wing and conservatism but still make it look more sane than "crazy illogical feminism".
And then boom, you have abortion rights being taken away in USA and men are getting control over women, again. Meanwhile VICE gets dumbfucks to represent "feminist" side of debate and supports women by constantly warning women to know their place and that men in dresses come first, always.
No. 9656
>>9633SWERF and
TERF are redundant. Radfems are TERFs and SWERFs by default.
No. 9667
>>9633Radical feminism isn't trans exclusionary because sex cannot be changed. They started calling us terfs because it doesn't make them look good to criticize feminism. That's why calling yourself a
terf is a self-own. Just call yourself a feminist. Transgenderism wasn't even a thing before, it was called transsexualism. They are constantly redefining themselves and feminism to control the discourse.
No. 9705
File: 1675474768580.png (256.26 KB, 474x377, b81.png)
How do you terfpill your friend completely? My previously SJW friend has started to realize how shitty troons are after we joined a discord server with a bunch of misogynistic TIMs and started calling them troons kek but she still defends "the good ones".
No. 9776
File: 1675738358982.jpeg (14.16 KB, 275x201, 1584840380821.jpeg)
Not trying to incite a flame war or anything of that nature, but how do you guys respond to the "have empathy" sort of arguments? I'm a rational person, I understand what biological sex is and know that a man can never be a woman BUT I still find myself sympathizing with people who claim to suffer from gender dysphoria etc. They all are so obviously mentally ill and unhinged. I don't think any of their trans shit makes any sense, but I also don't feel like it's that big of a deal sometimes to support their delusions. I call them by preferred pronouns etc and just smile and keep my true thoughts hidden. Sometimes being "transphobic" just feels like kicking a small, ugly puppy. I'm still stuck in that era where trans shit was classified as a mental disorder and just like with people with depression or psychosis, I feel sorry for them (the ones who aren't harming anyone, anyway).
No. 9780
>>9776Because the small puppy that's actually getting kicked is the future you're allowing for the next generation of girls and women.
These males are counting on women's empathy and they literally get off on every "you go girl" you give them. Even moreso when you're uncomfortable.
No. 9786
>>9776Turn it back on them, ask them to have empathy for you, for women in general. It's not going to win the argument because there's nothing to reason with, but the response might help you see hollow the hypocrisy is.
I feel sorry for drug addicts. They are suffering and are just looking for relief, even if it's in the wrong place. I'm not going to go out and buy them meth and tell them their scratched up skin looks nice and encourage them to keep poisoning themselves. They need rehab. But if you suggest that trans people should be counselled to love themselves in the body they're in and to rethink gender roles, TRAs label that conversion disorder. Voice training, costumes, cosmetic surgery, recruiting other people into pronoun use, somehow that charade isn't conversion therapy but self acceptance is. Do you think that's really empathy?
No. 9797
>>9776First of all what
>>9786 said
>ask them to have empathy for you, for women in generalWhy is it that YOU have to deny biology and science, pretend you really think men are women, and allow them into female spaces even if they're convicted rapists. Why aren't you allowed to say "sorry, it's ok that you wear a dress and I support your right to wear it but I don't think you should change in the female room when you have a dick and many women here have been sexually assaulted" and if you do say that, THEY might get violent and punch you and the whole establishment will still think it's YOU who should get kicked out and banned from coming back. When has denying science ever been a good thing?
Now imagine the most "innocent" kind of troon, a man who is shy and autistic and clearly just not that understanding of social roles, so he thought thinking dresses are pretty and not liking sports makes him a woman. Do you think little 5 year old girls should have to see his dick in changing rooms? That they should be trained to think men having their dicks out around them when they are undressing is something they must accept, and if they're alarmed or uncomfortable in any way they are evil and bigoted? And that shy autistic man should be allowed to look at these naked 5 year old girls, because… he's shy and autistic? Or because maybe he's gay and that makes him "safe"? And when a non-trans convicted pedophile comes in with his dick in his hand they wouldn't know a difference, he could just be a transwoman.
And may I also remind you that the vast majority (85%+) of transwomen are both attracted to women, and will never have the sex-change surgery. Meaning they have functioning dicks that get hard when they see women or girls they find attractive. Now imagine a 13 year old girl in the changing room, she's on the heavier side and hit puberty a few years earlier and her size makes her look a little bit older and curvier. She's bled through her underwear and has to take off her bloody panties in shame, she doesn't know what to do or who to ask. He's watching it all. But she still has to change, and in doing so expose her developing breasts to this man, he gets to see all of her developing body really. He is autistic and socially unaware, so he stares. And she notices. She knows he's a man and she old enough to know about sexual assaults, and that she can't say anything because he's trans. But what if he wants to hurt her? Or touch her? Is he going to pull a Dylan Mulvaney and approach her with tampons? So he can tell her how to insert them into her underage vagina, like we've seen countless troons fantasize about? Even if all he does is stare in silence, she's scared and traumatized. She's hates her female body now, if only she had been a guy this wouldn't have happened.
I have empathy for mentally ill people. Which is why I don't tell anorexics that they're fat and should lose more weight, that their bones poking out are beautiful and
valid, that not eating at all for 7 days is brave and stunning. Because actually playing along and affirming their delusion is cruel and hurts them further. And every little girl watching me praise the anorexic would start to feel they're too fat as well, that they also shouldn't eat for 7 days, and now I'm complicit in spreading the mental illness to everyone around us. It hurts everyone.
The ONLY "good" reason to affirm troons is for your own safety, because they are mentally ill males and they could turn violent if you say something they dislike.
No. 10296
File: 1676653490108.jpeg (122.48 KB, 663x1000, 14C38EB5-E59A-4947-820D-DF6862…)
>>4098Any nonas here who read that “controversial” book? In terms of my views, nothing changed since I peaked a few years ago, it was mostly things I already knew but it was good to read anyway. I like that it might lead some more people into questioning the trans thing, especially in regards how it targets girls and women. Some most talked issues are discussed here, such as social contagion or a reference to TIMs getting into women’s sports.
I still found this book lacked some things for me. I wish there was more about Tumblr and especially how social media promote transness in fandom spaces (such as by headcanons about characters from various media), the issue how the trans crowd is targeting autistic girls (and how one branch of people celebrating neurodiversity lumped it with queerness and degeneracies like trans), why some teenagers become trans because they come from
abusive families and have severe trauma in regards to body or interpersonal relationships so the trans thing seems like getting a new, better identity for them.
Once or few times I think I was confused why the author seemed to connect being tomboyish/not being stereotypically feminine with lesbians. Like, I appreciate she wrote about how the erasure of the word “lesbian” is a problem, how young girls seem to connect that word with porn and how they escape womanhood via transness but I felt like orientation and style/behavior are two different issues. For example, I consider myself tomboyish but I’m not a lesbian. And not all lesbians have to be tomboys or butch either.
I feel like it’s a topic that can give much more material to be discussed, many things are still left to describe but at least it seems like a good thing to start for some. I hope this book will gain attention again and people will be able to read it without prejudice.
I read a PDF of this book and today I had a crazy thought, what if I could get a few copies of that to redistribute to some places in my city, like bookcrossing shelves?
No. 10335
>>9656I’m a radfem but I don’t consider myself a SWERF. I hate porn but most sex workers are
victims and should not be excluded from feminism. If you disagree that’s fine but I think there is a place in feminism for all women. I’m a
TERF because men are not women and never will be.
No. 10338
>>10335I honestly thought that this was a core tenet of radical feminism?
SWERF to me means that you reject sex work, not the women that are
victims of it. Realizing now that this was a misleading assumption
No. 10380
>>10335SWERF is a boogeyman term to ostracize and shame feminists who are against sex work itself. There are women who are awful towards sex workers and shame them or call derogatory names, but actual radfems acknowledge that they are
victims of misogynistic industry and treat them like any other women.
No. 10383
>>10360>we should focus on biological sex only in terms of thinking about things like women's spaces etc? Yes
>is there ANY merit to gender identity? No
>furthermore, wouldnt it be impossible to remove the idea of gender, bc we inevitably will link certain traits with each sex?The 'idea of gender' is literally just sexist stereotypes and gender roles (or fashion styles, judging by the way themlets and TIFs talk about it). It was only ever meant to be a synonym/euphemism for biological sex, gendies have taken the term and bastardized it.
No. 10416
>>10360I don't consider myself a radfem tbh, just gender critical
>do most of you guys feel that gender should be abolished entirely, and that we should focus on biological sex only in terms of thinking about things like women's spaces etc?Gender the way trans ideology defines it simply doesn't exist. They say everyone has a "gender" that is separate from their physical body, your sex. If they match you're cis, if they don't match you're trans. This gender can mix, be fluid, change, be several at the same time, you can be also be agender and not have a gender which means that IS your gender… anything goes in trans ideology. All is
valid. So it's exactly like a soul/spirit, meaning their "gender" is a religious/spiritual belief.
It doesn't matter to them that the people they call cis in 99% of cases say "actually no, I don't feel I have a gender at all, and I do not define myself as cis" (despite them also accepting agender as trans) trans people just don't accept that. You have a gender and you're cis no matter what YOU think. Just like a religious person (let's say christian) just considers a non-believer to be a lost soul and that they need to find Jesus. They don't understand or respect that the atheist and buddhist simply don't agree that their god even exists. The christian thinks you are wrong, despite there being no evidence of anything they say, because they "feel" it's true so it must be. Trans ideology thinks that gender exists without any proof, if you disagree you are a lost non-believer.
The other thing gender means (the way normal people use the word) is really just a substitute for the word "sex", as relating to male and female. Trans ideology actively rejects this original use of the word, so to them this version of gender doesn't exist. "What gender is the dog?" is just less crude in English than "What sex is the dog?" and that seems to be the only reason why it exists. My native language didn't even have this distinction and had to make up a word for gender to be woke lol
What sex we are matters. Even in a perfect ideal society where we are all treated equal without any oppression, our bodies will still have different functions. Your sex is programmed into every single cell of your body, you can't ever change it. The natural variations within the 2 sexes, or the fact that a small number of people are born with sexual developmental disorders, doesn't change this whatsoever. A woman who is born without a functioning uterus still has a body designed around the function of giving birth and will still be affected by diseases exclusively for females. This is still true even if you pump her full of testosterone and try to make her appear more like a man. Likewise a man born without functioning balls still has a body designed around producing sperm. The 2 sex split is way older than humans, even plants are male or female.
>wouldnt it be impossible to remove the idea of gender, bc we inevitably will link certain traits with each sex?"Gender" in the original meaning of the word, as a substitute for sex, was perfectly fine. We can just go back to that. Sex exists without gender, it's gender that is dependant on sex to exist because it's based on stereotypes of the 2 sexes. When people say that the statement "pink and dresses are for girls" is a " female gender stereotype" it really just means it's a stereotype of the female sex.
No. 10693
>>10657yes. this, and what it says about the entirety of the medical industrial complex along with a handful of unrelated topics/issues have made me realize public narratives are just that: narratives, someone pushing something is usually total nonsense.
in general there's absolutely been a crisis of loss of public trust. evaporated in me now from things like this and living my life.
No. 10700
>>10360Like the nonna above I'm also mostly just gender critical but interested in other parts of radical feminism that don't just have to do with that
>do most of you guys feel that gender should be abolished entirelyI do agree with this but think it would be impossible to maintain for very long on such a large scale. Maybe I'm just pessimistic.
>is there ANY merit to gender identity?"""Gender identity""" is literally just personality traits that anyone could have. Like
>>10416 said, in gender ideology everything is a goddamn gender, and gender is separate from genitals. Isn't that just called… having a fucking personality?
But according to their logic, what otherwise would've been considered a normal personality must be a magic essence, like a soul, that is tied in a way (matching or not matching) to your genitals, or sex. So they already contradict themselves there. They say your body doesn't determine your gender, but they still use terms like "cis" or "trans" for whether your personality "matches" (in their sexist minds) your body (actually just sex stereotypes). Meaning that, for them, biological women are genetically predisposed to develop a personality that makes them wear tons of makeup every day, buy tons of cute shoes and exclusively like pink kawaii shit. And when a biological man does any of that, it means he has the magical soul of a woman. It's almost as if they took the very same stereotypes and traditional gender roles that say "you're a woman, you can't do anything other than this" or "women are all stupid, vain and childish", and re-interpreted them backwards: "if you're a man who likes pink stuff, you must be a woman." Transactivists seem to take things way too literally, you can see it in
everything they say.
"Cis" and "trans" are both made up terms for a condition that doesn't exist. You'd think cis just means being comfortable in one's body (as I thought before peaking), but no, it means that you feel that you match the stereotypes associated with your sex, and if you express any doubts as to whether you're gender non-conforming, that means you're trans and should probably take hormones even if you're ok with your body. But if you don't believe in that sexist crap, the term loses all meaning as there can be no real category or identity such as cis, because not conforming perfectly to gender norms is not a special, biological or psychiatric condition, it's something perfectly normal because sex stereotypes and ideal male/female standards were largely made up by human society, and no one ever perfectly matches that standard. In troon logic, that would mean we're all "trans", and that's where you realize that gender theory is retarded.
There is no biological basis for it. It's only based on stupid and purely cultural sex stereotypes that have only limited every aspect of our lives for millennia. To believe in gender theory is to reinforce those very same opressive sexist rules. You can go against cultural gender norms to different degrees, and hate those gender norms to death, but that won't make you "cis" or "trans", or the opposite sex or no sex, or any particular "gender". You're just you, with your own traits that are unique like everyone else's, you have things in common with some women but not with others, in a female body that automatically makes you a woman, which is a category that doesn't have to affect your personality, but affects your role in sexual reproduction, among a few other things that are strictly biological and unchangeable. Gender ideology believers refuse to acknowledge any of that.
>>10380>SWERF is a boogeyman term to ostracize and shame feminists who are against sex work itself.Exactly this, something that libfems and porn/prostitution supporters who pretend to be progressive have always done, is conflate criticism of sex
work with hatred towards prostitutes or sex
workers, who they don't see as
victims of misogyny but as normal workers engaging in sex work in a completely voluntary and harmless manner (because they want sex "work" to be treated as normal and not something vile and degrading). SWERF is a very disingenuous term that implies we hate those women, and for the same bullshit reasons religious or conservative people do, when in reality we just had the gall to say that prostitution and pornography are bad for them.
No. 10778
I want to preface this by saying that I'm not GC or a radfem in the slightest, but get called a
TERF a lot by MtFs because I hold the sentiment that lesbians don't like penises, and gay guys don't like vaginas and what have you. I'm more of a "transmed" I guess, which is only critical of certain aspects of gender.
I recently had an unhinged MtF in my Tumblr inbox calling me a
TERF because I said the idea of having sex with a male revolted me, and he tried to use a bunch of fuckin insane leaps in logic to harass me. I don't believe in respecting pronouns other than "he" or "she," but site culture and the lack of GID from this moid makes me lean on "he."
I don't think I will ever peak, because I have been treated like shit by people who have, and other personal experiences. But my god, do I hate MtFs most of the time. I've met a couple chill ones but most are the most perverted, insane "people" I have ever met. I run a (now dead) Tumblr blog where I used to larp as an incel but now I think I need to target MtFs instead
No. 10802
File: 1677310845679.png (119.94 KB, 623x392, FpLZDEwX0AAU1g3.png)
not saying correlation is causation but this is interesting, a lot of insecure over socialized young women/girls with access to the internet would take up some new identity to feel better about themselves
No. 10811
Sorry if it's already been talked about, but I recommend watching the video "A Record of Our Dissent: Violent TRA Assault on Women at the NYC Let Women Speak Event" by Skirt Go Spinny (pretty sure the username is ironic since the channel seems to be gendercritical). It shows unedited footage from the #LetWomenSpeak protest and how violent troons got towards them.
I tried to share it but I got an error, but here's the link
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpC1sv6oHM No. 10919
File: 1677593102470.jpg (260.13 KB, 1000x1000, two spirt.jpg)
"Enlighted" third genders be like"
>feminine men kicked out of the male sex
>women treated as celibate pseudomales because their family didn't have any sons for inheritance
>little boys dressed as women that were being raped by male nobles
>eunuch court officials
So progressive and forward thinking
No. 10946
File: 1677629884079.jpg (200.63 KB, 1080x1269, Tumblr_l_392705082626038.jpg)
Trannies are acting like we're devastated by this, but it's literally the first time I'm hearing about it, and my response is just… so what? She's a cool person with one dumb opinion. I still respect her even if I don't agree with all of her positions. That's a thing you can do. Absolutism is retarded, and you'll go insane if you refuse to listen to or support someone if they disagree with you on just one thing.
Dworkin was also sympathetic to troons, but I still enjoy her writing and respect her. Her overall philosophical matters more to me than her take on a fad that was in its infancy during her life.
No. 10965
>>10951I don't care too much either, I know they're still just ignorant like we all were before peaking. The left is rabid when it comes to shunning people and never talking to them again if you even dare to question something they say. The right is (surprisingly) more open, which is the complete opposite of what I would have believed. I've seen right conservatives reach out to talk to trans people, but the leftist handmaidens would rather die than hear a word of what the right says.
I also know I have to lie about it myself to internet mutuals and pretend that I think men are women for my own safety, so I'm not ruling out other women being secretly peaked too.
No. 12179
File: 1679643556195.png (125.11 KB, 995x1711, cvbnkkjhgfdsdfghjk.png)
Holy shit I just found out about this and I'm so fucking pissed. Screenshot is the wiki article where I learned about her so you can see the retardation for yourselves.
Amelia or "Amelio" Robles Ávila was one of many women who took part in the Mexican Revolution, not (just) as a passive housewife, mother and prostitute from the sidelines, but as a soldier in the frontline. These women that participated in combat were called "soldaderas" or "Adelitas". Some of them disguised themselves as men so they'd be allowed to fight and to avoid discrimination from their male peers. Some of them became famous for their feats in battle and amazing combat ability, and eventually revealed their real sex, but few of these got the official recognition they deserved at the time, due to the brutal sexism in a culture of pure machismo.
But Amelia didn't just disguise herself as a man to fight. She was a lesbian that grew up as a tomboy, learning to ride horses and shoot, which were considered strictly male-only things at the time. Sadly, she was a TIF. After she started to crossdress, she would get aggressive when people called her "ma'am". She was and is still officially recognized by the army as male due to her dedication to her "male" identity, and some people think this is good and progressive instead of horribly misogynistic.
It baffles me how people can seriously learn about her and the rest of the soldaderas and still support erasing her from Mexican women's history by considering her a man. She was
only given her well-deserved recognition by the army AFTER she publicly changed her name and gender, while other female soldiers who fought for WOMEN to be recognized and acknowledged as competent warriors and as heroes on par with males were treated like garbage (for example, Petra "Pedro" Herrera). If you support this shit, you support the explicit (not even implicit) misogyny in it.
>Ooooh, the first trans person to be officially recognized in Mexico! So heckin' valid!! They totally supported LGBTQIA+++ rights, so heartwarming!!All I get from her story is that women faced such brutal misogyny at the time that she loathed everything about being a woman, in part because she wasn't allowed to be female and do what she wanted, which happened to be "for men only", and no doubt because women were seen as inferior too, even worse than in the present, and most importantly due to the sexual assault that she faced during the war. It's not hard to see why she'd want to be a man, and perhaps she didn't have a choice back then, but recognizing her as a man and celebrating her self-hatred and complex trauma as a result of the oppression that she and other women were
victims of in that era, requires a special kind of cognitive dissonance. And the worst part is that society, even
her own family, and so-called "progressives" then and now, readily accepted her as a (fake) man as if being a woman who uses firearms, wears pants and is attracted to other women was somehow worse than a woman hating her own existence, as if they were congratulating her for wanting to be "the better sex", instead of giving her the respect she deserves as "the inferior sex". Like they were telling her "you're one of the few good women who deserve to be called men". That's
literally what happened when she was decorated by the army because she had a FAKE birth certificate that said she had been born male. The army would've hesitated or refused to honor her properly if she hadn't been so desperately trying to become a real man in the eyes of others, let alone if she had demanded to be respected as a woman.
I'm glad the CNDH (National Human Rights Commission of Mexico) still refers to her as female in this article, at least before the part where she "came out", but on the other hand they still do the stupid "assigned female at birth" bullshit. It's like they still have a bit of common sense and aren't sure if it'd be better to support women or support gender ideology:
https://www.cndh.org.mx/noticia/nace-amelia-robles-avila-lider-revolucionaria-quien-se-le-reconoceria-como-el-valienteAlso, what the hell is this? From the English wiki article:
>Robles was not alone as a person assigned female presenting as male in the Mexican army at the time. Maria de la Luz Barrera and Ángel(a) Jiménez also adopted male identities during the warWas it really necessary to use this roundabout troon language to describe women who were definitely not TIFs? It's so fucking annoying.
They only use these unnecessary terms for two non-troon women because they're being mentioned in reference to the subject who is a TIF. So in a way whoever edited this shit is acknowledging that the TIF in question is just like the other women, a woman pretending to be a man. That's kinda funny.
No. 12180
>>12179I actually have read about her story, the one interesting detail TRAs leave it out is the fact on her deathbed she be asked to be dressed as a woman in order to commend her soul to god and that she be given full military honors
I don't think she can be compared to a modern TIF, she grew up in a very religious environment and probably believed that she wasn't "allowed" to love another woman as a woman and had to take the role of a man
No. 12469
>>10919There is a reason why this pracitce
>https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-63904744died out, save for a few remnants.
>Although there are no exact figures, it is estimated that there are only 12 burrneshat remaining in Northern Albania and Kosovo. No. 12581
>>12533>It is a cruelty to pretend what they have done to their bodies is anything other than horrificThis is so true. It's so easy to compare to eating disorders when it comes to the troons who actually do have gender dysphoria, because it's the same base condition of body dysmorphia. They're just different expressions of the same kind of mental disorder.
Imagine someone with a severe eating disorder, who's all skin and bones through starving themselves. You know they're hurting, or at worst even killing themselves through this.
They hit a new low goal weight, "don't I look so much better like this than when I was fatter?" they ask.
It would at first seem cruel to be honest and say "No, you look terrifyingly sick and it's kind of repulsing. I wish you'd stop and get help." But it also wouldn't be kind to say "yes, you look better now, you're going in the right direction" because you are then pushing them to continue to hurt and kill themselves. Only one of the options allows for the person to get out of the disorder, and the other pushes them further into it. So which reaction is REALLY the empathic one?
No. 14549
File: 1682950345805.png (74.52 KB, 624x590, data says.png)
>>14548kek I love her deadpan german humour. just subsribed.
glad to see the consequences of transitioning being spoken about openly and honestly, with decent data to back it up. and I also like that she brings up the social contagion element. there were one or two things that rubbed the wrong way in the first half though, like:
>transgenders are stigmatised around the world, being forced into a strict masculine - feminine binaryumm those are gender roles that everyone is unfairly subject to. and trans people reinforce them. I think she is confusing gender nonconformity and transgenderism here.
No. 14584
>>10298I'm the nona you're replying to, thank you! I don't know if I'll wrote a book about it (I thought of writing books but on different topics). When I saw your reply (sorry for not replying earlier) I thought it inspired me to make a gender critical Substack though. So far I don't have any posts yet but I have some drafts. I will certainly share it here when it will be ready.
I plan to write posts based on my observations and some of my irl experiences with troons.
I will write it in English, which is not my first language but will be better for larger audience.
No. 14587
>>14549Well the first part of the video she lays out how the DSM defines the disorder, that's not necessarily her personal opinion. She didn't go after the general psychiatric consensus, only after bad studies. That's as much as a physicist can do as it's not their field.
She does go HARD after issues in particle physics in her videos as that is her field of study. I love her critiques of how "bro physics" negatively impacts science.
No. 14890
File: 1684597109006.jpg (175.01 KB, 1080x1173, Screenshot_20230520_162153_edi…)
Saged for ot but I was randomly scrolling through Facebook and saw a mass peaking event. Woman exploded at genderfag for saying women never have to feel unsafe, there were 400+ comments and almost all other women commenting were agreeing with her. I like seeing the normie peak kek 1/2
No. 15032
Regarding sports, in the 90s and 2000s, there was a pop-feminism trend focused on proving that girls are physically equal to boys and that anyone opposed to girls and boys competing against each other is a sexist man who needs to change his ways. I remember in TV shows like Hannah Montana, Degrassi, Proud Family, and Lizzie McGuire, all had episodes where female characters were not allowed to join a team with boys but did anyway, defeating sexist males easily, and at the end of the episode, the coach realizes he was wrong and changes his stance. This may have led to the idea among some young woke women who never actually did sports and are adults now, that there is no significant physical difference between male and female and anyone against boys and girls competing against each other is just sexist.
No. 15046
>>15032I've seen older feminists than me with this idea and it's only harmed them in the long run to realize women are physically smaller and weaker than men. Which to us who weren't sold the same lie over and over… well duh. There are even some nonas on here who will flip a table over if you try to say women and men on average have brains that differ in how we think and it's simply biological and not "fe/male socialization".
At no point has denial of biological reality helped humanity.
No. 15117
File: 1685339979105.png (50.72 KB, 1290x688, Screenshot 2023-05-29 at 06.58…)
The redditors on the small subreddit r/Jazz Jennings seem like they are slowly peaking. 1/4
https://www.reddit.com/r/JazzJennings/comments/12lwfu7/i_dont_feel_like_myself_ever/ No. 15722
File: 1686620192715.jpg (44.27 KB, 763x302, tumblr_99d8901a07f496e1a2a93f1…)
I hope they all 41% themselves
No. 15829
File: 1687193108823.jpg (784.97 KB, 4096x3276, GridArt_20230619_094337686.jpg)
Old news but how much of trans discourse and talking points are a result of Russian chaos agent propaganda kek
No. 15841
File: 1687240894537.jpg (624.5 KB, 4096x3276, GridArt_20230619_230116434.jpg)
>>15836It definitely should have its own thread! The chaos agent blogs generated an insane amount of buzz on their posts so one could still find some of them by googling their usernames.
https://help.tumblr.com/hc/en-us/articles/360002280214-Public-record-of-usernames-linked-to-state-sponsored-disinformation-campaignsThe nevaehtyler blog has a decent amount of popular posts against "white feminism". If their goal was to sew discourse and divide people, then I find that quite curious given how people online today think white women don't experience misogyny and TRAs and leftist moids label radical feminism as white feminism.
Most of the blogs operated between 2016-2018. Similarly, I really wished I saved this but there's a graph out there indicating that so many LGB news sites exploded in articles about troons all of a sudden around 2016. Any other nonnas interested into digging into this psy op?
No. 15856
>>15829>>15836This is incredible. Please make one. I have some insight into this, too.
I'm also convinced the LGBT's T was actually originally harmless, but infiltrated by outside sources to destroy gay, lesbian and bisexual's progress. I am not sure who (conservatives, russians, government) but it was an outside source with a ton of money.
T was actually very quiet when I originally joined and I remember discussing this with gay men and other lesbians and bisexual women that it was kind of like an orphan we took in because it had nowhere else to go for representation. I think malicious outsiders waiting in the shadows saw this and artificially pumped it (notice all the sudden support and push for it, corporations backing it) out of absolutely nowhere. I know this is hard to imagine, but trans people used to be very humbled to even be in LGBT when I was first apart of the community. They were nothing like what you think of the trans community now.
One theory I have was T was infiltrated and pumped up artificially by NAMBLA (the pedo organization. lots of rich billionaire pedophiles) who has been trying to insert itself into LGBT every single decade. Every single decade, we kick them out. I think they were aware of this, trying new tactics and decided to go for the weakest member of LGBT. Notice how aggressive they are with trying to make kids trans, when it used to be only for adults. What even is a "trans kid" and who started that phrase and push? Who's putting these gay, trans, and lesbian explicit sex books into schools? It's not us, that's for sure.
Now T somehow rules over and is destroying the safe spaces of LGB, especially for lesbians. It was definitely done on purpose and is malicious. The LGB is more hated than ever, aggressively pushed on straight people and families when that is not what Pride or the entire movement was supposed to be about.
No. 15872
File: 1687374897466.png (1.14 MB, 1280x1125, NLISAP-20210624-Pakistan-Afgha…)
>>15856I believe the Russians probably just took advantage of it, Its just one of the many things they promote to sow division in the United States, however I do agere with you, I think the issues of troon activism were likely started and promoted by pedophiles, if you look up historical examples of societies with pederasty, it seems they preferred feminized young boys above all else, most likely trans-activism is just a way to normalize and achieve their fetish.
No. 18621
>>18620Many tifs transition because they hate women and they hate being women. In their eyes, being a gay man is better then being a straight woman, being a straight man is better then being a gay woman, being a feminine man is better then being a feminine woman, being a masculine man is better then being a masculine woman, and so on and so forth. Women are vapid and 2d when compared to moids in their eyes. They've been told that women are week feebleminded creatures that lack nuance, and instead of growing up and realizing that women can be gay, straight, masculine, feminine, and have interests and feelings they internalize their self hatred and start to think since they identify as male they must make up for their sin (being female) by acting like an Elliot Rodger clone. Sad but true
No. 18634
>>18620Because they're stupid as fuck. They grew up hearing women are weak, vapid and stupid, and instead of going "hang on a minute I'm not weak, vapid or stupid so they're idiots who are spreading lies" they instead incorrectly think "hang on a minute I'm not weak, vapid or stupid so i must not be a woman like them".
A person (male or female) can't be a troon without misogyny and narcissism.
Tims think women aren't really their own thing and don't respect women enough to realize he can't ever be one. He sees women as "weaker men", and thinks that he can become one himself by becoming weaker.
Tifs think other women are weak and stupid and want to escape from being one. The ones who want to escape womanhood because they're scared still live under the illusion that all other women enjoy being oppressed and seen as stupid sexual objects, and that they themselves are special because they don't want it.
They're all mentally ill, there's no mentally stable troon. A mentally stable person simply don't live under the delusion that they're a different gender or sex than what their physical reality is. And mental illness causes depression in a lot of causes, and depression causes a high level of self-indulgence and narcissism (it's a pretty natural reaction, because when you're doing badly your body and brain tries to keep you alive by focusing resources on yourself). So even people who aren't "true" narcs become more and more narcissistic the more trans (mentally ill) they become. Doesn't help that trans ideology rewards narcissism and is built around it.
No. 18648
>>18634Your post is perfect at summarizing rationales of TIFs and TIMs but a part of it is a bit iffy.
>because they're scared still live under the illusion that all other women enjoy being oppressed and seen as stupid sexual objects, and that they themselves are special because they don't want it.Media and other women certainly depict this as not the case. Libfems and Libfem lites are the majority of all women after all that occupy social movements, media and influence and hold the most political/capital power and they do enjoy being degraded. "Awoken women" (whatever you consider this as) are aware of the ruse of degradation, male violence and are often female separatists, and female exclusive women etc. but you're being disingenuous arguing most women are against degradation. Most women are meagrely spineless supporters of this degradation by their silence and lack of deference, and most if not all as libfems are avid supporters. "Radfems" (the label doesn't matter) aka critical women with spines that question male violence, female humiliation and degradation are far less common and that makes TIFs even more bleak and resolute in their decision to troon out. They certainly suffer from mental illness to actually think anyone can change their biological sex but it's an entirely rational response to an irrational women-hating world. Internalized misogyny and self hatred is the only response to the current state of being a women in the world.
No. 18694
>>18672>but if you actually talk to them they'll agree that it's all bad and should be changed.Then why is there hardly any talk of this? Most are unquestioning and continue to go about their daily lives in acceptance of truly vile shit that barely lives under the surface of daily life. No lobbying, no attention paid to it at all. Most women are libfem lites in the anglosphere as they've fallen for the left/right doctrine in these countries and aside from a few outliers, most of the western world is like this too.
>>18673>Where do you live where there's not an outcry of these things?NZ, but isn't this the norm of the anglosphere? Am I somehow missing the swaths of women protesting, lobbying, and vocalizing their dissent against this? Barely any women are critical of troons let alone the inhuman treatment of children and women. How long can it keep being said that these women ignoring human trafficking simply aren't aware of this?
>>18677>but if I showed you real life it would be seen as a ragebait anywayPlease do, 'female pigs' anon.
No. 19426
File: 1692908358828.jpg (133.29 KB, 1192x600, large-tfjTOqErJVZbt6kDzG71ysHc…)
Rósisín Murphy has said something fairly reasonable about puberty blockers and her fag fan base is absolutely malding.
No. 19555
Trans Insurrectionist Calls on Marjorie Greene to Help Her Avoid Going to a Men's Prison. Jessica Watkins was charge with sedition for his role in the January 6th protests.
He founded and led a small militia in Ohio. He's like Republicans to help him serve his time in a women's prison. Marjorie Taylor Greene said no.
https://www.cleveland.com/crime/2023/05/ohio-bartender-gets-prison-for-leading-militia-into-capitol-attack.html No. 19740
File: 1694122182395.jpg (264.44 KB, 1022x690, Q4Msbs9.jpg)
I see a lot of people despairing about how long it's taking for the public and for leaders to allow and embrace scepticism towards the trans movement's claims, but it makes sense it is taking so long. The trans movement wasn't built in the day. The modern day trans movement dates back to the 90's. This book from 2013 positively talks about TIFs at Smith college (all woman school) including transgender issues into the Lesbian Bisexual Alliance club in the 1990's. It took them decades of convincing academics and college students to get to this point, it will take decades to move on.
The most important thing is to talk to other college students. Zoomers, especially nerdy zoomers, are beyond obsessed with gender. They're going to graduate and control future institutions. Those of you still on college campus, you need to find each other and start networking, talking to each other, promoting actual feminist theory and feminist action.
No. 19745
>>19740I think the best way to peak people is to point out how deranged it is to put literal kids on experimental puberty blockers that we KNOW hurt them permanently in terrible ways, and then point out how they all blatantly lie and call them "reversible". If they truly and honestly wanted to help "trans children", why would they deny how harmful they are when they only hurt trans children? (Not that they're a real thing, and detransitioners who they hate exist too but in their TRA eyes they are only given to real trans kids and only 0.01% detransitions and it's because of transphobia).
The only reason kids are given these experimental drugs in the first place is because transition for adults did NOT work. They only theorized that "well maybe if we started earlier they'd pass better and be more successful" and that led to puberty blockers. That's so fucking dumb, it's like saying "well the lobotomy didn't work on adults so let's do it on kids too to see if it works better then". It doesn't, it's just even worse!
Why wouldn't they if they actually cared about trans kids instead admit the flaws and advocate for safer blockers to be developed? Why wouldn't they be outraged that such unsafe drugs are used on trans children? The simple answer is that they're so far gone they can't admit that they've been loudly and aggressively WRONG this whole time. They would rather keep hurting more kids than admit to being wrong - because it was never really about the kids for them. It's about protecting the ideology at all costs.
No. 19781
File: 1694368069194.png (87.16 KB, 787x691, e36996f25d706baa76cc02d8af358f…)
i just like this post and wanted to share it somewhere.
No. 20036
What is this fucking bullshit? I just looked up "Intersex" on Wikipedia:
>Intersex people are individuals born with any of several sex characteristics including chromosome patterns, gonads, or genitals that, according to the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, "do not fit typical binary notions of male or female bodies".>"do not fit typical binary notions of male or female bodies">>15872>Its just one of the many things they promote to sow division in the United StatesWhile they undoubtedly used this and many other things to their advantage, Russian intelligence is not alone. The American elite also has many ways to sow division among the normal population to keep them distracted and loyal, especially if it's profitable in some way as is the case of transgenderism. See:
>>15847This was definitely not just a "tinfoil", it was definitely the truth. They do it on imageboards too, we have proof that the feds used 8chan. They do it on any website that's big enough. They've done it countless times in real life too.
Think about it, aside from those Russian or whatever agents there was already an American pro-troon agenda funded by tranny billionaires and their corporations. Besides, gendies also exist in Russia so it can't all be a big Russian conspiracy, trannies over there were able to change their legal sex, get surgeries and everything, and now that they're apparently banning SRS it's being used in western propaganda to attack Russia. It's a global phenomenon, and I believe it originally started in Western Europe (though pedophilia and autogynephilia are just male nature).
No. 20127
File: 1696151910295.jpg (9.58 KB, 261x209, TNGO.jpg)
No. 20128
>>20036>on WikipediaNona wikipedia will allow chaging of a child rapists pronouns the second he says he's just a little girl like his
victims. They've also scrubbed articles about how like half of male serial killers in the US were also cross dressers and similar things that make trans people "look bad" no matter how true it is. It's not new, wikipedia isn't as good and honest as they claim to be.
No. 22089
>>22088if the child is male he'll grow up to either kill himself or become a degenerate pedo.
if it's a girl she'll become hardcore Catholic tradwife and end up with someone like varg.
No. 22215
>>15856I've seen internet discourse, but more specifically tranny discourse, destroy several movements in front of my eyes (ecological defense, animal rights, refugee support etc.).
I don't believe tranny discourse is purely glowie psyops, but it sure is convenient for various powerful groups that all these cohesive and purposeful movements have suddenly devoured themselves from the inside, and they've obviously had some help.
No. 22600
File: 1707905082323.png (30.57 KB, 645x246, low_IQ-trannies.png)
A study has found that puberty blockers can lower IQ by one standard deviation.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-13077445/Top-neuropsychologist-puberty-blocker-drugs-given-trans-children-lower-IQs-reveals-three-journals-rejected-biased-research-scolded-using-sex-based-terms-like-male-female.html>Her alarming study highlighted cases where young girls seemingly lost between 7 to 15 IQ points while taking the medications, which halt bodily changes in puberty. Trannies being retards is now fact.
The establishment tried to stop her from publishing her findings probably because it would eat into the profits of pharmaceutical companies
>But despite the concerning findings, Professor Baxendale initially struggled to find a publisher for her review. >Three separate journals rejected her paper in which she called for 'urgent' research into the impact of the drugs on children's brain functions. No. 22931
WPATH files leaked:
https://environmentalprogress.org/big-news/wpath-filesI’m glad “gender medicine” is being compared to lobotomy because sterilizing children is definitely gonna be one of those things we look back on in abject horror in the same way. I hope they keep pushing the money angle because it’s obvious it’s largely profit-driven but once the profit factor of chaining children and retards to the medical system through transition is negated by the potential losses from the malpractice factor then I think we’ll actually start to see things change. It’s cynical but nobody cares about the ethics they care about the money. God I hope this tranny ship starts to sink. Please please please
No. 22938
File: 1709645021943.png (135.25 KB, 900x2197, radicalfeminism.png)
First time I'm seeing it all explained so succinctly and it's coming from a crossdresser male
No. 23595
File: 1711677757979.jpeg (441.19 KB, 828x619, IMG_9975.jpeg)
I hate these fucking trannies fucking making videos on lesbianism or female ssa as if they know anything. Idk where to post this because I don’t want to get redtexted for alogging but I just hate it so much I WISH IT COULD STOP. It’s so fucking annoying, YOU DONT KNOW THE LESBIAN FEMALE GAZE YIU ARE A MAN YOU ARE THE PROBLEM it pisses me off so bad it makes me want to be publicly gender critical but then I’d lose my irl friends (who are all into gender bullshit) but i struggled for so long to make friends I don’t want to throw it all down in the drain. This was such a stupid post but seeing this on my recommended and looking through this channel makes me want to pull the plug and not go online ever and just give up on being crypto and just telling them about their bullshit straight up.
No. 26702
File: 1721065200934.png (52.43 KB, 700x252, women only like pastel colors.…)
Sorry if this isn't the right thread, but I wanted to post this somewhere. I was binge-reading the retarded Aesthetic Wiki today, and I stumbled upon the "Kawaii Gamer" page. Picrel is one of the first paragraphs.
I think it shows pretty well how our gender socialization is done and perpetuated in really subtle ways. I had to laugh at the part about "sacrificing their femininity". The fuck is that, Becky? Do black headphones give you seizures or something? Are these people for real?
Everyday, every second, we are getting hammered in our minds how women should act, think and what aesthetics or colors we must like. Gaming is black, and black is men of course (sarcasm), so we turn it pink for the girlies. How the fuck is this not sexist? Why is no one saying something? Because it's normal and it's the norm. We still have a long way to go. I wonder if we will ever get rid of gender stereotypes.
No. 26763
>>26702Most women perpetuate these stereotypes happily. Most like being painted as stereotypically feminine, in online spaces especially. These women want different treatment from moids, they want to be judged on their appearances above all else and they want to express themselves as the most feminine amongst each other. Women aren't allowed to say this since it goes against the creed of 'be nice' all girls get indoctrinated with by a young age. I've become so numb to this that I don't fight it anymore. If you've lived long enough it's a depressing commonality. The reason why intelligence isn't cared about in women is this. Women have no one to blame but themselves for this. Probably doesn't entirely belong in this thread but the OP image echos this sentiment. Tranny doctrine is just one step away from regulated, self performed gender role nonsense after all.
>>23595>verilybitchie>bitchyLol men fucking hate women with an undying passion. Even in the tranny moids handle he thinks women = catty self deprecating sassy "bitch". Very progressive, very brave.
No. 26820
>>26786Blackpill is another way of moid apologism indeed. I knew a girl who would spam us with ALL MOIDS ARE GENETICALLY EVIL REEE I HATE FEMALE BODY MADE TO BE RAPED BY MOIDS ALL HET SEX IS RAPE doomerism all day long and then would do extreme mental gymnastics to rationalize her
abusive father's comments that were super rude and degrading. She would go speechless and terminate the convo whenever someone would point out that the reason she pushed the all men are evil by birth so much was because she wanted to excuse her dad's assholery as something innate rather than an intentional move on his part to belittle her.
No. 26865
>>26820>Blackpill is another way of moid apologism indeedbased and true
>>26786>To the containment thread with youHonestly I'm pretty new here and I'm relieved if it's seen as a containment thread. I was hoping the whole board wasn't like this lmao
No. 26923
>>26786>and moid apologismHow? I apologise for no moid. But idiotic women doing the same are not
victims.
>Don't act like moids don't reinforce this cute aesthetic on women tooWhen did I say this? Schizoid one. I agree with you. You're making mountains out of mole hills. At the end of the day women are the ones wearing makeup and cute aesthetic things and reinforcing this. Men cannot through this means apart from a few exceptions. You're completely conveniently ignoring this reality. Grow up. We all live under this pressure and I've experienced it from males in my life too, that doesn't change the fact that most women are still reinforcing this.
>>26867Accountability is apparently difficult. I suppose it's hard to live in reality and see women pushing this shit left right and center. At the end of the day people's anecdotal experiences don't mean much when a majority of women in society push for this as the norm. You're living in denial if you ignore this and claim it's only moids fault. It speaks of immaturity.